Home
/
AAA games
/
Franchise updates
/

Aaron judge graces mlb the show 26 cover as star athlete

Aaron Judge Takes the Spotlight | MLB The Show 26 Cover Athlete Causes Stir

By

Kamara Nascimento

Jan 27, 2026, 11:10 PM

Edited By

James Lee

Updated

Jan 28, 2026, 04:26 PM

2 minutes of duration

Aaron Judge smiling and holding a baseball bat, featured on the cover of MLB The Show 26 with a vibrant background
popular

Major League Baseball fans were surprised when Aaron Judge was announced as the cover athlete for MLB The Show 26. This choice, coming after his previous cover in 2018, has caused a mix of reactions in the community.

Fans Express Frustration

The decision to feature Judge again has not sat well with many baseball enthusiasts. Comments include observations like, "I know that Judge had a great season, but this is a super boring choice, right?" Another added, "They specifically said this year's cover wouldn't be someone new, so it was going to be a repeat."

Debate Over Repetition

Discussions center on the lack of variety in cover athletes. One fan suggested, "Shouldโ€™ve put Big Dumper on the cover. More interesting sports story this year," highlighting a desire for fresh choices. Interestingly, some voices in the crowd argue in favor of Judge, noting, "Heโ€™s on an unprecedented run. Heโ€™s basically twice as good as the average hitter."

Key Themes from Community Feedback

  1. Repetitive Choices: Many feel that past covers diminish the excitement.

  2. Call for New Talent: Thereโ€™s a push for showcasing emerging players, as fans feel options are lacking.

  3. Platform Availability Concerns: Ongoing queries about the absence of the Nintendo Switch version fuel dissatisfaction.

Notable Comments from Fans

"No Switch 2 version wtf?"

This reflects the growing frustration regarding platform support.

What's Next |

While gamers await the release, questions loom about new features and gameplay updates. Pacific Northwest gamers in particular are vocal about the absence of a Switch version, pointing to uneven development as a possible cause. With Sony San Diego facing criticism, the community is eager to see how these issues will be addressed.

Key Takeaways:

  • ๐ŸŒŸ Many find Judgeโ€™s re-selection underwhelming.

  • ๐Ÿšซ Mixed feelings loom about the game's future decisions.

  • ๐Ÿ’ฌ โ€œHeโ€™s basically twice as good as the average hitterโ€ - comment backing Judge.

The sentiment fluctuates within the community, and the decision regarding the cover athlete raises questions about the direction of MLB The Show. As the release date approaches, will fan feedback spark a shift in future cover choices?