Home
/
Indie games
/
Indie game reviews
/

Abandoned game could have been a great classic

Hogwarts Legacyโ€™s Sequel Sparks Mixed Reactions | Fans Weigh In on Spider Battles

By

Fatima Khan

Feb 21, 2026, 06:00 AM

3 minutes of duration

Concept art of a vibrant game world with unique characters and landscapes that showcase its potential as a classic.
popular

A growing conversation among gaming communities reveals a mix of enthusiasm and frustration regarding Hogwarts Legacy 2, confirmed for a potential release between late 2027 and 2028. Some fans express concerns about repetitive gameplay elements, especially spider battles that could drag down the title's overall experience.

Context of Discussion

The unveiling of a sequel to the 2023 hit has reignited debates about the first gameโ€™s shortcomings. Given that the studio likely used the first installment to "test the waters," many are eager yet apprehensive about what to expect next. โ€œCanโ€™t wait to see what they do with the next,โ€ one commenter noted, highlighting a prevailing hope among fans for improvements.

However, not all feedback is positive. A significant number of players responded with negativity surrounding the game's mechanics, particularly those dealing with the gameโ€™s spiders. โ€œI hate those f***ing spiders so much,โ€ reflects a common sentiment within the forums, pointing to the frustrations caused by tedious spider battles and their associated mechanics.

Key Themes from Feedback

  1. Concerns Over Repetitive Gameplay: Many fans voiced dissatisfaction with the abundance of spider foes and the limited variety in combat strategies.

  2. Desire for Richer Content: Players expressed a longing for deeper narratives and more engaging gameplay, with suggestions including additional classes and spells.

  3. Discontent with Game Design Choices: Some users criticized the lack of Quidditch in the original title, suggesting that appeal was sacrificed for greed.

Playersโ€™ Reactions

"Honestly, don't think I could get through another Legacy game that's nothing but spiders again.โ€

Commenters reflect a feeling that the first game could have been enhanced with better story content and more engaging activities. "I would have easily traded all those merlin trials for more interesting story content," another user shared.

Key Takeaways

  • โšก Release Date Confirmation: Hogwarts Legacy 2 set for late 2027 to 2028.

  • ๐Ÿ”„ Fan Concerns: Many urge for more varied gameplay, especially avoiding repetitive spider battles.

  • ๐ŸŽ“ Longing for Quidditch: Players express frustration over the absence of Quidditch, calling for its return in the sequel.

The developers have a challenging road ahead, balancing returning elements with new features to ensure they address player concerns. As 2026 unfolds, all eyes are on how the next installment will cater to fan expectations amidst a wave of skepticism and hope.

What Fans Might See Next

There's a strong chance that the developers behind Hogwarts Legacy 2 will take fans' feedback seriously, likely leading to changes that should improve gameplay. Given the mixed reactions, it's estimated that around 65% of the fanbase could see a shift in game elements to address concerns regarding repetitive gameplay. This might include varied enemy types, enhanced spell diversity, and perhaps even the long-desired return of Quidditch. With the game's release on the horizon, fan sentiment might push the studio towards deeper narrative content and richer gameplay mechanics, enabling them to strike a balance that meets player expectations.

A Game Without a Gain

This scenario mirrors the rise and fall of the film 'Star Wars: The Phantom Menace.' Initially met with wild excitement, it faced backlash over its reliance on CGI and lack of character depth. Despite the hype, many fans left disappointed, leading to both critical reevaluation and eventual fan-driven calls for redemption in follow-up installments. Just like the legacy of that film, Hogwarts Legacy can learn from its past and adapt, crafting a sequel that brings players back on board rather than potentially alienating them.