Spoilers Spark Controversy | Why Abby Forced Ellie to Witness Joel's Death
Edited By
Darius Kingston
Abby’s brutal choice to make Ellie watch Joel's demise has ignited heated discussions across multiple forums. Gamers are questioning the motivations behind such a grim act in the narrative, especially considering its emotional weight.
Context of the Controversy
The distressing scene where Abby forces Ellie to observe Joel's death struck a nerve with many people. While some frame Abby as a villain, views diverge on the writers' handling of character arcs, leading to accusations of poor storytelling.
Key Themes from Forum Comments
Characterization of Abby: Many threads depict Abby as a sadistic antagonist, with quotes like "Because Abby is a sadist. She gets pleasure from seeing others suffer."
Ellie's Suffering: A significant portion of the discussion revolves around Ellie’s relentless pain, emphasizing that "she literally loses everything and has to endure the worst of everything."
Writing Critique: The writing choices are widely criticized. Multiple comments echo the sentiment: "Bad writing" and criticisms surrounding the writers’ apparent disdain for favorite characters like Joel.
"Caring while someone is, crying, screaming, and begging was a huge misstep by the writers." - A user reflects the sentiment of many.
Sentiments Reflected in Comments
While negativity dominates among users regarding the writing decisions, a few lighter comments brought a chance for reflection on character motivations.
Key Takeaways
🔥 Questionable Motives: Abby's actions are seen less as revenge and more as sadistic pleasure.
❗ Ellie's Fate: Many feel Ellie received a raw deal, with no respite from suffering.
📉 Criticism of Writing: Significant backlash against the writers for poor character handling.
In a nutshell, the intense reactions from forums showcase a community deeply invested in character arcs and storytelling quality. As the debate rages on, one wonders how this will impact future narrative developments in the series.
What Lies Ahead for Abby and Ellie?
There's a strong chance that the next installments will address the backlash over Abby and Ellie's intense arc. Writers may opt for a redemption story for Abby, aiming to shed light on her motivations. Alternatively, they might double down on the narrative by pushing Ellie further into despair, creating a stark contrast between her suffering and Abby's actions. Many expect this could lead to a thrilling yet darker continuation, predicting around a 70% likelihood of some narrative shift by the developers in response to these heated discussions.
Reflecting on the Human Condition
In a striking historical parallel, one can look at the impact of the French Revolution on individual narratives. Much like the community surrounding the game's story, people back then found themselves deeply divided by the shifting allegiances and brutal choices made by leaders in power. The tension felt by many today over fictional characters reflects that timeless struggle between oppressor and oppressed, revealing how the human experience continues to evolve through the lens of empathy and moral questioning, not just in art but in life's greater narrative.