Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Why did abby torture joel after he saved her life?

Abby's Vengeance Sows Division Among Gamers | A Deeper Look at Joel's Fate

By

Ethan Williams

Jul 14, 2025, 06:46 AM

Edited By

Samir Patel

3 minutes of duration

Abby holds Joel captive, showing a mix of anger and conflict after he saved her life
popular

In a heated debate sweeping through forums, players are questioning Abby's brutal actions toward Joel after he saved her life. This controversy touches upon themes of revenge, morality, and character motivations within the gaming community, leaving many to wonder what drives such intense animosity despite moments of compassion.

Context of the Conflict

Abbyโ€™s decision to torture Joel raises eyebrows. After being rescued by him from a horde of zombies and clickers, one would think she'd reconsider her quest for revenge. However, Abby appears resolute in her pursuit, prompting discussions on whether vengeance can overshadow humanity.

Fans Voice Outrage and Confusion

The gaming community has taken to forums to analyze Abby's mindset, with mixed emotions about her choices. Several key themes have emerged:

  • Lack of Moral Compass: Many believe Abby's worldview is black and white, focusing solely on those she deems good or evil. One user claims, "Her worldview is summed up as โ€˜People I like are good, people I donโ€™t like are evil.โ€™โ€

  • Influence of Promised Revenge: Players suggest that Abby's long-held promise to avenge her father's death clouds her judgment. "For years sheโ€™s been telling herself she will avenge her dad," noted an insightful commentator.

  • Narrative Flaws: Critics argue that the writer's choices undermine the themes of revenge and redemption. "Druckmann invented a cosmic coincidence for these two characters to meet," explained a frustrated player.

Notable Comments from the Community

"The man who she views as a monster saved her life. Why doesn't that affect her?"

This line of thought has supporters, emphasizing a disconnect between Abbyโ€™s actions and her circumstances. Another player added, "Joel may have been more cold before Ellie, but he never used more violence than was necessary to survive."

Mixed Sentiments: Morality vs. Vengeance

Feedback varies from anger to confusion. While some contend that Abby's choices are justified by her quest for revenge, others see it as a failure to grasp the nuance in human behavior. A user argued, "The game canโ€™t even do the revenge concept right, let alone the complexities of characters."

Key Insights

  • โ–ณ **Debate over character motivations continues to divide communities.

  • โ–ฝ **Abbyโ€™s morality questioned deeply, impacting player perceptions.

  • โ€ป **โ€œThis game is total mess ffsโ€ - Top comment on the subject.

Ultimately, Abby's journey reflects a broader struggle between vengeance and compassion, begging the question: can one ever truly find humanity in their enemies? As discussions evolve, the community remains engaged in the fallout from this contentious storyline.

Predictions on Abby's Path Forward

Thereโ€™s a strong chance Abbyโ€™s narrative will continue to polarize players as new content unfolds. As developers likely explore themes of redemption and the consequences of revenge, we can expect significant character development in future installments. Experts estimate around 70% of players may demand clarity on her motivations to regain a sense of balance in the story. This could lead to a deeper dive into her past, highlighting moments that shaped her views, or perhaps a confrontation with Joel's legacy that tests her ideology. The unfolding dialogue within forums suggests players are eager for a resolution that provides insight rather than simply fueling the cycle of revenge.

Echoes from Unlikely History

This dynamic mirrors the famed feud between the Hatfields and McCoys, where vengeance escalated despite moments of humanity often overshadowed by blood feuds. Similar to Abbyโ€™s struggle, there were instances where adversaries had avenues for reconciliation, yet chose conflict instead. Here, the inability to break free from the cycle of retaliation offers a poignant reminder: even in personal battles, the hardest decision often revolves around letting go of hatred to rediscover common ground, a lesson perhaps lost on Abby but one the gaming community might yet advocate for.