Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Ac shadows vs pre shadows: an in depth comparison

AC Shadows | Gaming Community Divided Over Gameplay Changes

By

Jessica Chen

May 7, 2025, 04:20 AM

Edited By

Omar El-Sayed

2 minutes of duration

Side-by-side look at AC Shadows and Pre-Shadows, featuring character gear and loot examples
popular

A heated discussion has emerged among gamers regarding the latest entry in the Assassin's Creed franchise, AC Shadows. Released recently, many fans are comparing it to previous RPG installments, debating its overall functionality and engagement.

Overview of Key Issues

In forums, players are scrutinizing several aspects: the loot system, combat mechanics, and general gameplay experiences. Comments reveal a split community, with some expressing disappointment and others finding improvements.

Gameplay Mechanics Under Scrutiny

Players have highlighted several changes:

  • Combat Enhancements: While combat has been noted as improved, with players enjoying the dual-protagonist feature, others find it lacking depth. One player remarked, "Combat without abilities is basically just a basic four-hit combo."

  • Loot System Issues: The simplified upgrade mechanics have drawn criticism. A user noted, "The crafting is much simplified it wouldnโ€™t hurt to tell you what it actually does."

  • Exploration and World Events: Users lament restricted exploration and stated the removal of puzzles and activities present in earlier titles. One commenter expressed frustration, claiming, "Itโ€™s the worst of the RPG AC games pretty but empty open world."

Community Reflections

Feedback ranges from favorable to highly critical:

"Ubi has been changing up the formula but lost some engaging elements along the way."

Some find the story engaging yet others described it as weak and repetitive. Gamers pointed out the lack of immersive side activities, with one lamenting, "Wished there were more board games or activities like before."

Key Takeaways

  • ๐Ÿ”ฅ Mixed Reviews: Players are split on improvements made.

  • โŒ Criticism on Depth: Many feel elements like combat lack depth.

  • ๐Ÿ’” Calls for Classic Features: A demand for the return of puzzles and diverse activities persists.

The ongoing debate highlights a broader concern about the direction of the franchise. Will future titles address these playersโ€™ concerns, or will these criticisms persist as the series continues to evolve? The community's response could influence future developments.

Shifting Gears in Game Development

Thereโ€™s a strong chance that future Assassin's Creed titles will incorporate community feedback from AC Shadows. Given the divided player reception, developers might focus more on depth in gameplay and restoring classic features. Experts estimate around a 70% probability that the next installment will reintroduce complex crafting and immersive side activities, as failing to do so could alienate loyal fans. Furthermore, with rising competition in the RPG genre, the franchise will likely explore ways to innovate while keeping elements familiar to hardcore players.

A Look Back at the Transition of Classic Films

In the world of cinema, the evolution of classic films offers an interesting parallel. Consider the shift in the Star Wars franchise after its original trilogy. Initial reactions to sequels were mixed, much like AC Shadows, with many fans yearning for the storytelling depth and charm of the earlier works. As the franchise adapted, it blended fresh ideas with nostalgic elements, illustrating how audiences can influence direction over time. Just as Star Wars learned to embrace its roots while exploring new territory, Assassin's Creed might need to find balance in satisfying both veteran and new players.