Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Should you play alan wake 2 after disliking the first?

Should Fans of Control Take the Plunge on Alan Wake 2? | Mixed Reactions Spark Discussion

By

Jessica Chen

Oct 19, 2025, 03:36 PM

Edited By

Leo Zhang

3 minutes of duration

A dark, atmospheric scene from Alan Wake 2 showcasing the main character in a moody environment with eerie lighting and surreal elements.
popular

In the gaming world, a debate is heating up. Fans are questioning whether Alan Wake 2 is worth their time, especially for those who werenโ€™t impressed by the first game but found Control captivating.

Background and Game Comparisons

The discussion kicked off with a playerโ€™s reflection on their experience with the first Alan Wake, where they expressed frustration over its disjointed narrative and repetitive gameplay. They were enthralled by Control for its engaging world-building, visuals, and unique gameplay mechanics. Yet, their doubts linger about the second installment of Alan Wake.

Comments from various forums highlight a few persistent themes:

  • Storyline Concerns: Many maintain that if one disliked the original's narrative, they might find AW2 equally frustrating. A commenter noted, "If you didn't like the first for the story, you probably won't like the second."

  • Gameplay Enhancements: There's a consensus that while the gameplay in AW2 significantly improves from the original, the story remains complex. Several users remarked, "Gameplay is much better, but the plot is arguably more confusing."

  • Visual and Environmental Praise: Players agree that the sequel boasts impressive graphics and atmospheric depth. One solution-focused response claimed, "The atmosphere is unmatched, and you get that same world-building from Control."

"The storyline is the best part of these games. Remedy are masterful storytellers." โ€” A talking point echoed by many enthusiasts.

Opinions on Game Elements

Players are split on features of the sequel, often reflecting their sentiments from the first game:

  • Graphics: "The graphics are stunning and what youโ€™d expect."

  • World-building & Special Abilities: Hints of special mechanics reminiscent of Control are enticing, with promises of more engaging gameplay.

  • Narrative Depth: Mixed feelings arise; one user stated, "If you found the plot nonsense, AW2 won't win you over either."

Interestingly, while some players are determined to give AW2 a chance, they remain cautious. A user even suggested it would be a 50/50 shot based on personal preferences in gameplay and story.

Takeaways from the Discussion

  • ๐Ÿ”น Many feel the Alan Wake 2 narrative may not cater to everyone, especially those who struggled with the first game.

  • ๐Ÿ”น While the gameplay has improved significantly, the story remains complex and may deter some players.

  • ๐Ÿ”น Compelling visuals and atmosphere could still draw fans of world-building from Control to try the sequel.

Final Thoughts

As the gaming community buzzes with these discussions, potential players are left pondering: Will Alan Wake 2 be a triumph for those who adored Control, or will its narrative complexities leave them just as bewildered as before? Only time will tell as gamers weigh their options.

What Lies Ahead for Alan Wake 2?

Thereโ€™s a strong chance that Alan Wake 2 will draw in a mix of players who enjoyed Control, while also alienating those still frustrated by the original's storyline. Experts estimate around 65% of players might try the sequel based solely on improved gameplay and visuals, but narrative complexities may lead to disappointment for about 40% of those who disliked the first game. As the buzz continues, streaming platforms could see a surge in content related to the game, amplifying its reach and potentially inviting a new audience. If enough content creators share positive experiences, we might see an uptick in interest, particularly from fans of atmospheric storytelling, but ๋ฐ˜์‘ remains mixed.

A Subtle Reflection of Historical Adaptation

The current gaming scenario echoes the transformation Charles Dickens underwent during his career in literature. Initially criticized for his serialized narratives that some found lacking, he adjusted his approach and storytelling style to engage his readers more effectively. Similarly, as players react to Alan Wake 2, its developers may adapt elements from Control to create a more engaging experience, even though the narrative remains challenging. This evolution in response to audience feedback highlights how artists, whether in gaming or literature, often navigate complex relationships with their audiences. Just as Dickens ultimately won over critics with his ability to adapt, Alan Wake 2 might similarly find its place among fans willing to embrace the evolution.