Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Is atomic heart worth buying? mixed reviews split opinions

Atomic Heart | Gamers Debate Value Amid Increasing Criticism

By

Mila Novak

May 30, 2025, 11:47 AM

Updated

May 30, 2025, 12:50 PM

2 minutes of duration

Cover art featuring a futuristic landscape with a robotic character in a dystopian setting

A growing conversation among players over Atomic Heart raises questions about the gameโ€™s worth as mixed reviews flow through forums. Many are expressing their frustrations and varying opinions, causing potential buyers to wonder if they should invest their money.

Players Share Their Experiences

Comments reveal a myriad of sentiments on the gameโ€™s quality. One user scored it a cautious 7/10, noting the game is enjoyable but flawed. They said, "Some will strongly dislike it, others will like it despite its flaws." Others criticized it for its obnoxious main character and mediocre story, comparing it unfavorably to Borderlands.

Key Issues from the Forums

Three primary themes have emerged from discussions:

  1. Gameplay Mechanics: Many players enjoyed the combat and upgrade progression, highlighting its resemblance to Bioshock, while others criticized the game's pacing. Several users found the gameplay odd and the open world somewhat empty, saying, "It's dollar store Bioshock with a main character who shouts catchphrases that will make you cringe."

  2. Writing Quality: A large number of users lamented the immature writing, with multiple comments suggesting it feels juvenile. "If the writing is somehow worse than Borderlands, then Iโ€™m definitely passing," expressed a player.

  3. Content Concerns: The explicit nature of the themes sparked debate among the community. Critics argue the gameโ€™s tone may deter potential players, leading one individual to refuse to buy until geopolitical issues are resolved.

"The protagonist is so incredibly cringy I put it down after 4 hours," lamented a frustrated gamer.

Sentiment Overview

Overall, the atmosphere appears mixed, with many expressing disappointment contingent on personal preferences. The feedback could influence future sales and updates more than previously thought.

Highlights from the Discussion

  • ๐Ÿ”ป Reactions to Atomic Heart vary widely, with many feeling itโ€™s not worth the full price.

  • ๐Ÿ” Reviewers appreciate the combat mechanics but many are put off by the storytelling.

  • ๐Ÿ”บ "Itโ€™s a cool game but" - one comment reflected a mix of admiration and concern regarding the game's ties to Russian ownership.

As community discussions continue, will developers among the Atomic Heart team change their approach? Now is a crucial time for them to consider player feedback and possibly enhance the gameplay to satisfy a divided audience.