Home
/
Indie games
/
Indie game reviews
/

Choosing the best 2 d soulslike: which game to play next?

Choosing the Best 2D Soulslike: Insights from the Community | Fresh Recommendations

By

Emily Rodriguez

Jul 20, 2025, 04:58 PM

Edited By

Marcus Chen

Updated

Jul 20, 2025, 08:56 PM

2 minutes of duration

Various characters from 2D soulslike games like Salt and Sanctuary and Blasphemous fighting against enemies in a dark, atmospheric environment
popular

In the rapidly-evolving world of 2D soulslike gaming, players are sparking lively debates about the top options available. While Salt and Sanctuary, Blasphemous, and Nine Sols are frequently mentioned, many people are sharing new insights and recommendations that could reshape the conventional rankings of these titles.

Whatโ€™s Hot Among Players?

Players on various forums are evaluating their favorite 2D soulslike games, revealing nuanced perspectives on the genre. Strong opinions lead to spirited discussions about individual titles. New names are emerging from the clutter, and they include:

  • Grime: Called out for its innovative mechanics and engaging gameplay.

  • Mandragora Whispers of the Witch Tree: Praised for its classic Dark Souls vibes.

  • Afterimage: Receiving glowing recommendations for its compelling experience.

  • The Last Faith: Suggested for those specifically chasing a soulslike feel.

Enthusiastic Opinions

Contributors are weighing in with diverse comments on various games:

  • "If you want to parry like Sekiroโ€”Nine Sols is your pick," noted one player.

  • Others remark that the Salt series, while enjoyable, can be seen as "janky" and sometimes unfair.

  • One avid player summarized it best: "Grime has the MOST EXPLORATION I've ever seen in an Metroidvania; combat is polished and fluid."

Moreover, the sentiment suggests that while Salt and Sanctuary holds the crown, it faces mixed reviews for being mirrored too closely to Dark Souls. Several comments emphasize the lack of maps and confusing world design, making some players hesitant to fully embrace it.

Trending Recommendations

Among the chatter, here are the standout recommendations for those new to the genre:

  • For Parrying Fans: Nine Sols is highlighted as a must-try for its Sekiro-like experience.

  • If Viva Variety is Your Thing: Salt and Sanctuary takes the front seat here for its rich build options.

  • For a Unique Artsy Touch: Blasphemous dazzles with visuals but might not fit the hardcore soulslike mold.

  • A Worthy Fresh Title: Mandragora is described as a love letter to classic Dark Souls, signaling a strong choice for seasoned players seeking something familiar yet fresh.

Key Insights from the Forum Buzz

  • ๐Ÿ•น๏ธ Engagement: Salt and Sanctuary remains a popular choice, but its mechanics draw criticism for being steeped in Dark Souls.

  • ๐ŸŽฎ New Contenders: Enthusiastic recommendations for Grime and Mandragora indicate growing interest in diverse titles.

  • โš”๏ธ Mixed Reviews for Blasphemous: While noted for its aesthetic, many argue it lacks core soulslike elements.

As players unite over their shared gaming experiences, the discourse continues to evolve. Will Salt and Sanctuary maintain its status, or will newer games carve a niche in this competitive space? Only time will tell as players seek deeper immersion into their 2D soulslike adventures.