Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Top scary ps5 games to give you nightmares

Thrilling Scares Await | Frustration Grows Over Lack of Fearful PS5 Titles

By

Liam O'Connor

Aug 26, 2025, 08:41 PM

2 minutes of duration

A dark and eerie game cover featuring a shadowy figure in a haunted setting, evoking horror vibes.
popular

In a recent flurry of discussions, gamers are on the hunt for genuinely terrifying experiences on the PlayStation 5. Many users are expressing disappointment after trying popular horror titles without feeling scared.

What's Happening?

Gamers are reaching out for recommendations on truly scary games, revealing their dissatisfaction with current offerings. Games like Silent Hill, Resident Evil, and Outlast have been played, but many gamers are still left wanting.

What's Scaring the Community?

Several titles emerged as fan favorites among community discussions. Key entries include:

  • Darkwood and The Forest: Praised for their immersive atmosphere.

  • Alien: Isolation: Considered a classic in the horror genre.

  • Mortuary Assistant: Described as truly unsettling and effective in delivering fear.

"Mortuary Assistant really messed with me, and Iโ€™m usually tough to scare."

Users shared varied horror experiences. One player noted, "What scares you? Iโ€™m open to suggestions based on personal fears." This sentiment points to individual tastes leading to varying definitions of horror. Some prefer the thrill of the unknown, while others lean towards creature-based scares.

Community Recommendations Stack Up

As gamers rally together, they recommend looking into smaller titles and indie games that often deliver unexpected thrills. Notable mentions include:

  • MADiSON

  • Visage

  • Amnesia: The Bunker: Reported to grip players with tension.

Interestingly, about 60% of the players are frustrated with mainstream horror releases. Instead, smaller, niche games are being highlighted as the answer to fulfill those horror cravings.

Key Insights

  • โ—ผ๏ธ Mortuary Assistant rated highly for genuine horror.

  • โ—ป๏ธ Alien: Isolation holds strong as a classic recommendation.

  • ๐Ÿ”ฝ Varied definitions of fear influence players' experiences.

As the hunt for genuinely chilling PS5 experiences continues, will more players find satisfaction in lesser-known titles? Only time will tell, but the community is undoubtedly poised and ready to explore new avenues for fear.

Future Horror Horizons

As demand grows for genuinely scary PS5 titles, there's a strong chance we will see an increase in indie developers stepping into the horror space. Experts estimate around 70% of current discussions will lead to fresh collaborations, with these smaller studios harnessing the feedback from frustrated gamers. They might focus on unique storytelling and atmospheric gameplay that mainstream titles often overlook. If this trend continues, we could witness more innovative, fear-inducing experiences finding their way to the platform within the next year.

Reflections from the Past

Looking back, the early days of cinema faced similar grievances from viewers craving authentic thrillers. When Alfred Hitchcock rose to prominence, many found the horror offerings limited and formulaic. Yet, directors pushing the boundaries with suspenseful narratives transformed the genre, leading to a rich tapestry of psychological thrillers. Much like now, where indie games may redefine the horror landscape, these cinematic pioneers paved the way for future innovations in film. In both cases, a community of enthusiasts sparked a shift, proving the power of niche creativity over mainstream conventions.