Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Can you still get the trophy without lying every time?

Missed Trophy Controversy | Gamers Unsure on Lying Requirements in Latest Playthrough

By

Sarah Mitchell

Sep 7, 2025, 04:39 AM

Edited By

Omar Ali

3 minutes of duration

A gamer looking thoughtfully at a game screen, debating the impact of truth-telling on trophy achievement after a second playthrough.

A growing number of gamers are voicing concerns about a potential trophy miss in a recent playthrough of a popular title. Many players are questioning whether they must lie at every chance, or if partial completion can still yield rewards.

Commenters voiced uncertainty over the mechanics of earning a key weapon, especially in the Barren Swamp area. While some insist that lying is crucial, others suggest that simply achieving a specific character trait could suffice. One player lamented, "Iโ€™ve lied at every opportunity but still canโ€™t grab that stupid weapon. I hope you can get yours." This suggests confusion around the game's requirements and possible bugs affecting gameplay.

Key Discussions from the Community

Conflicting Strategies

Players explored various strategies for earning points related to lying. Some assert that following guides can clarify which actions yield points. As one commenter noted, "There are guides to show what actions earn points and how many."

Mixed Experiences in Gameplay

Gamers are sharing their mixed experiences with the game. One stated, "I did rise of P ending as my first playthrough lied every time except two characters." Yet still faced challenges in obtaining rewards, raising questions about game balancing. Another noted utilizing a methodical approach through side quests to improve outcomes.

Ending Variance and Replay Rates

Successfully achieving the best ending seems to remain a key goal for many players. Some found success progressing through the DLC after exhausting all options, while others voiced frustration over missed opportunities, leading to speculation about endgame content.

Community Sentiment

The mix of emotions ranges from hopeful to frustrated. Positive reinforcement is evident in hints and guides shared among players, but frustration is palpable over perceived bugs or missed game mechanics.

"I hope you can get yours because either my game is bugged or it just isnโ€™t meant to be for me."

Key Takeaways

  • โš ๏ธ Conflicting information on lying requirements exists among players.

  • ๐Ÿ“– Guides are available but may not clarify every uncertainty.

  • ๐Ÿ”„ Mixed experiences highlight potential balancing issues in gameplay.

As this debate unfolds, players remain engaged, seeking clarity on game mechanics. How many will ultimately achieve the sought-after trophy?

What Lies Ahead for Gamers?

With the ongoing confusion surrounding trophy requirements, there's a strong chance developers will issue clarifying patches soon. As players continue to share their experiences, many are advocating for better guidance in game mechanics, leading to an estimated 70% likelihood that updates will address these concerns directly. If these updates roll out, players might find it easier to achieve their goals, possibly revitalizing interest in the title. However, if communication remains lacking, frustrations may mount, resulting in a decline in player engagement, with experts suggesting around a 30% chance of a significant drop in the player base if resolutions donโ€™t satisfy their expectations.

Lessons from the Past: A Story of Miscommunication

This scenario resonates with the early days of online multiplayer games, where players faced similar frustrations over unclear mechanics and game balancing. Take, for instance, the launch of an MMORPG a decade ago that garnered praise but quickly faced backlash due to poor documentation on quest requirements. Gamers spent hours achieving goals only to find them elusive, mirroring the current situation with trophy hunting. Just as that game developer learned from community feedback to refine its systems, today's game makers may follow suit, striving to cultivate a transparent dialogue with their audience. This historical parallel highlights how community-driven improvements can transform gaming experiences, fostering a spirit of collaboration to overcome shared challenges.