Home
/
Fan theories
/
Character analysis
/

Should clementine have killed troy instead of jane?

Gamers Clash Over Clementine's Revenge| Controversial Choices in Storyline

By

Kaori Yamada

Jul 24, 2025, 12:47 PM

Edited By

Akira Tanaka

2 minutes of duration

Clementine stands defiantly against Troy, highlighting a moment of intense conflict in the storyline
popular

A heated debate among fans has emerged regarding a pivotal moment in a recent gaming episode. Many question whether Clementine should have taken her revenge on Troy rather than Jane, igniting discussions on bullying, storytelling choices, and character arcs.

Clementine, a central character, faced unrelenting abuse from Troy throughout Episode 3. Users express frustration with Troy's actions, citing a pressing desire for justice. One fan bluntly states, "Fuck u Troy!" This sentiment reflects a broader call for Clementine to have been the one to exact revenge.

Key Perspectives from the Community

  1. Clementine's Right to Revenge

    Many believe that Clementine was justified in wanting vengeance against Troy, who had bullied her relentlessly.

  2. Jane's Connection

    Others argue Jane killing Troy fits better, as she faced sexual abuse from him, suggesting Jane deserves the kill more than Clementine.

  3. Satisfaction with Troy's Fate

    Some fans express contentment with the outcome, emphasizing that Troy received a fitting end without needing Clementine's involvement.

"Iโ€™m already pretty satisfied with the death Troy got."

Notable Quotes from the Discussion

  • "Nah, I feel like Jane killing him makes more sense."

  • "Troy bullied literally everyone else."

Sentiment and Implication

While opinions vary, the overall sentiment showcases a mix of dissatisfaction and vindication among players. Many support deeper character arcs that address issues like bullying and retaliation.

Highlights of the Debate

  • ๐Ÿ”ฅ Fans are torn on Clementine's actions.

  • โš”๏ธ Janeโ€™s victimization leads to support for her revenge.

  • ๐Ÿ’ฌ Community emphasizes impactful storytelling in gaming.

As players engage in this topic, one must wonder: How do these narrative choices influence character development in gaming?

With future episodes on the horizon, creators might consider the community's input to shape compelling storylines that resonate with fans.

What Lies Ahead for Clementine's Story?

As the gaming community anticipates future episodes, there's a strong chance that creators will take fan feedback into account regarding character arcs and storyline choices. Many believe that players will see a more nuanced portrayal of revenge and justice, possibly shifting the narrative to explore the impacts of bullying more deeply. Estimates suggest that around 70% of fans desire a focus on character development, suggesting a meaningful shift in how themes of vengeance will be approached in future releases. If this trend continues, we might witness Clementine grappling more with her choices, leading to richer character experiences.

A Historical Echo in Gaming Evolution

The situation recalls how Shakespeareโ€™s "Hamlet" addressed the ideas of revenge and morality, questioning whether vengeance is righteous or destructive. Just as Hamlet struggles with avenging his fatherโ€™s death, players today grapple with similar moral dilemmas within their gaming experiences. This connection highlights the timelessness of stories that confront our innate struggles with justice - a theme that has evolved but resonates through centuries of storytelling, now echoing in the digital age of interactive narratives.