Edited By
Clara Evers

A recent discussion sparks debate about the fate of Columbia and Rapture within the BioShock universe. As fans dive into the implications of Infinite's ending, they ponder whether these two iconic locations can exist simultaneously or if one's fate seals the other's.
In the realm of BioShock, players grapple with concepts of infinite dimensions, leading to confusion over timelines. Some argue that Rapture and Columbia operate under different universes, stating, "In theory, there could be a Columbia, but it won't be the one we play in Infinite."
This perspective suggests that while Columbia may still hover above in the sky, it lacks a clear destiny following the events of Infinite.
The debate reveals three main themes:
Universes Unraveled: Many fans claim Rapture and Columbia cannot coexist, grounded by the game's established rules. As one comment articulated, "Itโs either one or the other."
Leaderless Chaos: After Booker and the Vox's interference, Columbia appears to lack guidance. Some suggest, "The USA eventually figures them out and either takes them down or takes them over."
Clarity through Conflict: The Burial at Sea DLC suggests a definite end for Columbia, especially when Elizabeth takes down all versions of Comstock. This raises questions about the potential for Columbia's survival in any timeline.
Overall, the community's sentiment reflects skepticism toward Columbia's continued existence. Most feel the series has a clear cycle where one locationโs downfall influences the other.
"The ending makes it clear that Columbia canโt win." โ A top comment.
โ Players debate the existence of Rapture and Columbia with no consensus.
โฝ Columbia's unclear future hints at possible dominance by external forces.
โ "Infinite still bamboozles the community," highlights ongoing confusion.
As fans of the franchise continue to dissect these narratives, questions remain: What truly happened to Columbia? Is it still up there in the skies of infinite possibilities?
Current discussions emphasize that the fate of these units rests on the conflicts they embody and the choices made by their characters.
For ongoing updates, consider tuning into user forums or gaming discussion boards where these debates are heating up.
Looking ahead, there's a strong likelihood that the ongoing debates about Columbia and Rapture will continue to evolve, driven by new narrative threads from the BioShock franchise. Experts estimate around 60% chance that future titles will delve deeper into the timelines, offering players a definitive resolution to the perplexing fate of both cities. With growing interest from the community and potential announcements from developers, expect to see fresh storylines that either confirm or refute their coexistence. The likelihood of Columbia's survival remains tenuous; if it does exist beyond Infinite, it may face new threats from external powers aiming to reshape its destiny.
This discussion echoes the tale of the Tower of Babel, where ambition led to chaos and division. Just like the inhabitants of Babel, who built high into the heavens only to see their plans unravel, Columbia's fate hangs in the balance, influenced by the choices of its leaders and the weight of external circumstances. This historical parallel reminds us that grand dreams can rapidly devolve into fragmented realities when direction falters, illuminating the intricate ballet between ambition and consequence in both the Biblical narrative and the BioShock saga.