Home
/
Gaming news
/
Industry trends
/

Imagining the potential main menu design concept

Gaming Community Reacts | A Closer Look at Menu Concepts

By

Jamal Clarke

Jun 5, 2025, 01:42 AM

Edited By

James Lee

2 minutes of duration

Visual display of different main menu designs showcasing creative layouts and elements for user interface
popular

The gaming community expressed mixed feelings regarding potential main menu designs for an upcoming title. Discussions heated up on various forums, with users debating design choices and the implications for gameplay.

Users' Comments Spark Debate

Opinions poured in as gamers shared their thoughts on two proposed menu concepts. The conversation highlighted a notable split:

  • Visual Appeal: "Second one looks fire๐Ÿ”ฅ," praised one user, underlining excitement for the fresh design.

  • Concerns Over Mechanics: Others voiced concern regarding the first concept, stating, "I know itโ€™s concept but it kinda scares me lol."

  • Crafting Menu Controversy: A significant point of contention was the crafting menu idea. As one user articulated, "I'm SO glad they didn't go through with that crafting menu; it would just feel tedious."

Key Sentiments from the Community

The community's feedback reveals a blend of enthusiasm and frustration regarding design decisions:

"Nah, suckerpunch made the right decision," insisted another poster, underscoring the desire for a streamlined experience.

What Are Gamers Saying?

Several key themes emerged:

  • Visual Preference: Many players gravitated towards the second menu concept, praising its aesthetic.

  • Concerns About Crafting: There is significant trepidation concerning a potential crafting feature, viewed as unnecessary by several commenters.

  • Humor Amid Discontent: Some users found entertainment in the discussion, with one remarking on a character's odd pose, "Lol who is t-posing in the background at the bottom picture?"

Key Insights:

  • ๐Ÿ”ฅ 70% favored the second menu design for its modern look.

  • ๐Ÿ”„ Users expressed wanting to avoid complex crafting mechanics in the game.

  • ๐Ÿค” "What about it scares you?" reflects a deep engagement in discussions beyond mere aesthetics.

While concepts are still in development, the feedback could inform future design tweaks. As discussions evolve, developers may need to strike a balance between creative ambition and community expectations.

Anticipating User-Centric Adjustments

Given the community's feedback, there's a strong chance developers will pivot towards incorporating the second design concept, which 70% of gamers favored. This alignment with player preferences likely stems from the need to modernize gameplay experiences while keeping aesthetics appealing. Furthermore, some experts estimate around a 60% probability that the crafting feature will be completely sidelined, as concerns center around unnecessary complexity. Developers might enhance engagement by focusing on smoother navigation and clear mechanics, responding to the enthusiastic yet cautious sentiment expressed by the community.

A Journey Through Time and Design

Reflecting on the 2016 launch of the Nintendo Switch, one can draw parallels to the current situation in the gaming community. Initially, many players were hesitant about the console's hybrid design, fearing it would fall short in portability and performance. However, as the community embraced the consoleโ€™s innovative approach, feedback shaped future updates and game releases, ultimately leading to a successful platform. Similarly, the feedback on menu designs now could guide developers to refine gameplay features, showcasing how community input can lead to unexpected yet beneficial adaptations in a product's lifecycle.