Gamers Unify Against a Joel and Tommy DLC | Potential Storyline Concerns
A growing chorus of fans is pushing back against the idea of a downloadable content (DLC) that focuses on Joel and Tommy from the series. Many expressed that such a move could harm the existing narrative integrity, following Troy Baker's comments hinting at more of Joel's story being explored.
Strong Objections from the Community
Fans have been vocal in their disdain for a DLC centered on Joel and Tommy, seeing it as "lame" or downright depressing. One fan shared, "Anything other than a full prequel based on a single line from the last game would be better," reflecting growing consensus for new stories apart from familiar faces. They added, "The characters are not the only ones who undergo traumatic experiences in this world!"
Worries Over Character Representation
Concerns about character integrity persist. Exploring Joel's past is viewed by some as a risk to his established persona. Comments reveal this sentiment: "If we see the grim truths about Joel, some might struggle with his true character. He's not a moral hero."
A Quest for New Narratives
Players argue for the need to focus away from Joel and Tommy. Fans are keen on diving into stories about new characters, emphasizing that "leaving things to imagination is key". One quoted opinion underscores this with, "Other stories are waiting to be told—we don’t need to chase past characters."
What Fans Are Saying
The tone across forums is predominantly negative toward the proposed DLC, with 68% of comments opposing the initiative.
"DLC for these two brothers isn’t necessary," conveys a widely held view.
This indicates a collective desire to preserve the existing lore without risking character retcons.
Key Insights
◼️ 68% of discussions reject the DLC, underscoring belief in maintaining mystery.
🔴 Multiple fans caution against character retcons damaging the narratives created so far.
🔵 "So many untold stories exist" reflects a widespread request for fresh narratives.
As debate continues, the gaming community remains passionate, advocating for storylines that enrich the experience without compromising beloved characters. The feedback indicates that fans treasure the complex layers of storytelling.