Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Storytelling decline in doom's new trilogy: an analysis

The Decline of Storytelling in Modern Gaming | Exploring the New Trilogy's Flaws

By

Nina Patel

Jun 18, 2025, 02:52 PM

Edited By

Liam Chen

3 minutes of duration

A DOOM Slayer character in a dark, dramatic setting, showcasing various transformation effects that highlight a shift in narrative depth.
popular

A growing number of people are expressing concern over the storytelling quality in recent installments of a popular gaming franchise. The latest entries seem to stray from the engaging narrative style that defined earlier versions, leading to disappointment and frustration among fans.

Context and Concerns

The recent discussions on forums highlight a trend where storytelling and world-building have taken a back seat. A user reflects that while enjoying the gameplay, the narrative depth of 2016's original title is subtly fading.

As this latest trilogy progresses, distinct changes in character portrayal are causing concern. Players note that the introduction of more cutscenes and a shift towards delivering dramatic backstories have diluted the once enigmatic aspects of the protagonist, known simply as the Slayer. This character, initially designed as a silent force, is evolving into a demi-god figure, diminishing the raw appeal of simplicity in earlier entries.

Quotes from the Community

"2016 was more show than tell. It lets the community fill in the gaps in an organic way."

This sentiment underscores a common belief that recent games rely heavily on exposition, which detracts from the immersive experience.

Another player noted, "The transition to grimdark has been poorly handled." This highlights dissatisfaction with how heaviness in tone clashes with the Slayer's previously straightforward persona.

Players Weigh In

  1. Character and Tone Conflict: Many players feel there's an inconsistency between the Slayer's grimdark characterization and the core essence portrayed in earlier titles. The shift to a serious tone doesn't seamlessly mesh with a protagonist lacking personality.

  2. Lack of Cohesion: A recurring theme in comments relates to perceived narrative disconnection. Ideas are thrown together without solid integration, leading to confusion.

  3. The Night Sentinels' Underdevelopment: Fans report feeling disconnected from the supporting cast, particularly the Night Sentinels, who fall flat compared to their portrayal in previous titles.

Observational Sentiment

The overall response blends frustration over diminishing story quality with an acknowledgment of the enjoyment found in the gameplay. Some say, "Theyโ€™re still mega fun games even if the story kind of goes to shit."

Key Points to Consider

  • โšก Players feel the narrative has become more complex yet less engaging.

  • ๐Ÿš€ Fans miss the simplicity and charm of the original storytelling style.

  • ๐Ÿ›‘ Significant criticism is directed at the portrayal of secondary characters who lack depth.

As this franchise continues to evolve, will developers recognize the need to balance compelling gameplay with rich storytelling? Players are clearly hoping for a return to the narrative strength that once defined the series.

Predicting the Course of the Franchise

Thereโ€™s a strong chance developers may heed community feedback and strike a better balance between immersive storytelling and gameplay in future releases. As fans express growing dissatisfaction over the narrative's decline, it is likely the franchise will pivot to prioritize character development and cohesive plot arcs. Experts estimate around a 70% probability that upcoming entries will feature more streamlined narratives, possibly returning to the engaging storytelling methods that initially captivated audiences. If the game's creators take a cue from successful franchises that have improved by listening to their communities, players might see a revival of the depth and charm that characterized earlier entries.

A Unique Historical Echo

This situation parallels the rise and fall of graphic novels in the 1990s, which initially drew audiences with compelling characters and engaging plots but later suffered from oversaturation and convoluted storylines. Just as the comic industry reevaluated its approach, leading to a resurgence in quality through simpler storytelling and character-focused narratives, the gaming world now faces a moment of reckoning. Developers could learn that sometimes less is more, reinforcing that simplicity often resonates more profoundly than complex narratives stacked with excessive details.