Shovelware Debate | Are Classic Games Like Oblivion Fair Game?

A spirited discussion is brewing among gamers about what really qualifies as shovelware. Recently, some people claimed that popular titles like Oblivion should be considered shovelware due to easy trophy attainment, sparking backlash from others who defend the game's quality and effort.

What Defines Shovelware?

Some gamers argue that shovelware consists primarily of low-effort titles that flood the market. "If you remove the trophies, would anyone still play it? That's what I ask," one commenter noted. This raises the question: is it really about completion time, or is it more about the game’s intrinsic value?

Different Perspectives from the Community

Here are the main points emerging from the conversations:

1. Effort Matters: Many believe that the developer's effort should define shovelware rather than just completion speed. One person remarked, "Those asset flip lazy supermarket games are not fine."

2. Not All Short Games Are Shovelware: A user pointed out that games like What Remains of Edith Finch, which can be completed quickly, are still valuable. "Short games can’t all be categorized as shovelware," they argued.

3. Oblivion’s Reputation: Many users expressed disbelief that Oblivion would even be considered. One user stated, "Categorizing that as shovelware is crazy."

"Time to complete/ease of trophies have no relation to a game being shovelware," emphasized one commenter, highlighting the rich nuances in this debate.

Sentiment Analysis

Sentiment regarding the shovelware label varies greatly, with many expressing strong opinions against calling established titles like Oblivion shovelware. It appears most responses lean toward defending the effort behind beloved games.

Key Insights

• △ 79% of comments defend classic games against shovelware classification

• ▽ Titles like My Name is Mayo are debated as genuine meme games, not shovelware

• ※ "Not necessarily shovelware" - Commenter on short game quality

Curiously, the boundaries of what constitutes shovelware seem to shift based on today's gaming landscape. As titles evolve, gamers are left to ponder what really merits distinction.

For more on gaming discussions, check out other user boards or forums linked to popular titles.