Home
/
Fan theories
/
Character analysis
/

Dishonored characters: why good people get hated

Dishonored Characters | Exploring Fan Hatred for Good Folks

By

Mila Novak

May 13, 2025, 10:39 AM

Updated

May 13, 2025, 01:23 PM

2 minutes of duration

A group of Dishonored characters standing together, showing contrasting expressions of frustration and kindness, reflecting mixed fan perceptions.

A spirited debate stirs in the Dishonored community, as players wrestle with their feelings toward certain characters. Recent discussions spotlighted Jindosh, who topped a forum poll, triggering fresh conversations about characters perceived as good yet facing backlash from fans.

Unpacking the Controversy

While some characters are meant to garner sympathy, many players find themselves annoyed by their actions. The discourse centers around a few key figures:

Galvani: A Complex Figure

Players continue to cite Galvani as a character who should be relatable yet often feels like a target of disdain. "It's wild that we can rob him multiple times across games; it really adds salt to the wound," shared one player. Notably, Galvani's properties appear in various locations throughout the series, enhancing the feeling of betrayal among fans. Another comment observed, "Heโ€™s portrayed as an amoral scientist, something bad, but you still canโ€™t ignore his struggles against the rat plague."

Vice Overseer Byrne: Caught in the Middle

Byrne also attracts mixed reactions. While some praise his pushback against antagonists like Delilah, his ties to the Abbey of the Everyman raise eyebrows. One commenter concisely summarized, "Heโ€™s always fighting the good fight, but heโ€™s part of an organization many despise."

Wallace: The Unsung Annoyance

Interestingly, Wallace has emerged as an unexpected character drawing ire despite his low profile. Comments suggest heโ€™s disliked without evidence of evil, with a user remarking, "Heโ€™s civil with superiors but a jerk to his subordinates. Just a dude trying to do his job, yet still annoying."

"Characters perceived as morally grey often spark the most discussion,โ€ noted another user, reflecting the communityโ€™s mixed sentiments.

Key Insights

  • ๐Ÿ”Ž Galvaniโ€™s multiple robbing opportunities (Dishonored 1 and Death of the Outsider) deepen the sense of conflict.

  • โœ๏ธ Vice Overseer Byrne is hailed for his anti-villainy stance yet criticized for his Abbey relations.

  • ๐Ÿ™ƒ Wallace emerges as a divisive character despite his unremarkable role.

The dialogues within the community underscore the intricate balance between character morality and player perceptions. As opinions bloom on forums and user boards, expect this narrative to continue evolving.

The Path Forward for Character Dynamics

As the Dishonored community keeps the conversations flowing, it's likely that interpretations of characters will shape future storytelling approaches. With polls influencing developer choices, character expansions likely hold a spot in upcoming context updates, possibly plunging into deeper moral quandaries. Players may find themselves questioning their biases against characters they once thought were straightforward allies or foes.

A Relevant Reflection

Casting a parallel to sports legends, the complex position of characters in Dishonored echoes controversies seen with figures like Dennis Rodman, whose polarizing nature sparked equally divided fan perspectives. Both highlight how complexities within a narrative make it more engaging while also prompting discussions about morality in storytelling.