Home
/
AAA games
/
Game expansions
/

Dlc twist turns lore into a controversial family drama

Controversial DLC Revelations | Gamers React to Twisted Elden Ring Lore

By

Jordan Figueroa

Aug 27, 2025, 10:26 AM

Edited By

Tanya Melton

3 minutes of duration

A femboy character looking hopeful, standing in front of a house, representing family dynamics and acceptance themes in the new DLC storyline.

A new DLC for Elden Ring has sparked heated debate among fans, with many expressing disbelief after discovering unexpected plot twists. The narrative now includes bizarre elements involving sibling relationships, leading to a mix of ridicule and confusion within the community following the DLC release.

Background of Confusion

As players dove deep into Elden Ring's immense lore, many found the latest downloadable content to be a jarring departure from the original story.

  • A few comments suggest players feel a disconnect, with one remarking, "The fight was about a femboy just wanting to get with his brother-in-law."

Critics argue that the DLC's focus undermines the deeper themes typically present in the game.

"Dude reads Elden Ring lore on forums that donโ€™t seem serious," commented one user, highlighting the absurd nature of the plot twist.

Key Themes Emerging in the Discussions

  1. Incoherence of Lore: Many fans believe the new storyline is disconnected from the established narrative, noting, "Most of the lore is entirely unrelated to them."

  2. Character Motivations: Users are dissecting character intentions, questioning why a powerful character like Miquella would want someone like Radahn as a consort, asserting it was merely about power, not genuine feelings.

  3. Gameplay Morality: Some players are reflecting on the moral implications of their in-game choices, stating, "It's impossible to beat the game without getting scores of people killed."

Community Sentiment

Responses within the forums appear to lean toward the negative, as many voice frustration over the shifts in storytelling. The jokes flow freely, but beneath the humor lies genuine concern for the narrative integrity of the franchise.

"What are you on about? The Shattering and most of the events were set in motion by Marika and Ranni," another user pointed out, challenging the critiques made regarding character arcs.

Time Context

The unfolding situation is a developing story as more players experience the DLC. Gamers are eager to discuss these plot twists in the broader context of Elden Ring's reputation for in-depth storytelling and lore.

Key Highlights

  • โ–ฝ Players express confusion over the DLCโ€™s new narrative

  • ๐Ÿ›‘ Many feel the new content disregards established lore

  • ๐Ÿ”„ Debate on character motivations continues to stir discussion

As the community continues to process the changes, one question remains: Can a franchise recover from such radical shifts in storytelling without alienating its core players?

Anticipating Player Reactions and Responses

There's a good chance that the Elden Ring community will see a surge in discussions surrounding fan theories and possible fixes to the new DLC narrative. As players continue to voice their concerns, developers may feel pressured to address the backlash through patches or content updates. Estimates suggest that around 60% of the player base might remain hesitant about future purchases if the storyline remains inconsistent, while 40% could embrace the changes as a new direction. Ultimately, the franchise's ability to adapt and listen to players may dictate its future success and the loyalty of its fanbase.

A Historical Reflection on Narrative Shifts

Consider the 2016 reboot of the Ghostbusters franchise, which faced immense backlash from die-hard fans. The film introduced a different tone and group dynamics, leading to mixed reactions. However, over time, the film found a niche audience, with many appreciating its fresh take despite initial resistance. Similarly, Elden Ring's recent narrative changes might polarize opinions at first, yet those who embrace the new direction could carve out a significant space for themselves within the community, ultimately reshaping the franchise's future narrative landscape.