Should Doom and Wolfenstein Merge? | Fans Weigh In on the Possibility
An ongoing debate has erupted among gaming fans regarding a potential crossover between Doom and Wolfenstein, two cornerstone franchises that have shaped the gaming landscape. While ideas for merging them run wild, opinions remain divided on whether these games, with their vastly different tones, should really connect.
The Familial Link Between Doomguy and Terror Billy
Community members have noted a seemingly clear relationship: the Doomguy from Doom is said to be a descendant of Wolfenstein's protagonist, Terror Billy. One commenter quipped, "Ain't that the plot of Zombie Army already?" This recognition leads to more questions about how the crossover could progress.
Interestingly, some fans suggest an outrageous narrative like, "What if Hitler opened a portal to hell?" Such concepts highlight the willingness to embrace humor in a crossover, albeit many shared skepticism about the primary tone of Wolfenstein being compromised.
The Contrast in Gameplay Elements
Forum comments indicate notable gameplay differences between the franchises. Doom thrives in chaotic, mission-driven sequences while Wolfenstein often features narrative breaks for character development and exploration. A user remarked on how Doom lacks the same storytelling breaks, stating, "2016 doesn’t have breaks; it’s all mission after mission."
Wolfenstein's current direction under MachineGames leans heavily on narrative depth. One fan stated, "Wolfenstein has delivered characters and ideas that I've found engaging through a historical lens," emphasizing the importance of rich storytelling in the series.
Community Sentiment on Crossover Potential
Responses to a possible merger reflect a broad spectrum of opinions. Some are enthusiastic, expressing a desire to see both protagonists united. As one fan stated, "I’d play it. Just let me murder demons and Nazis or Demon Nazis or Mecha Demon Hitler."
Conversely, skepticism remains prevalent. Numerous fans fear the fusion could dilute significant themes. A comment read, "I think the political commentary would be largely absent where it would now be expected, and the game would ultimately suffer for it," highlighting valid concerns over the franchise's integrity.
Key Takeaways
🔗 Connection Noted: The Doomguy and Terror Billy's lineage is acknowledged among fans.
🎭 Gameplay Differences: Distinct narrative and gameplay styles could pose challenges for a merger.
😬 Skepticism Abounds: Many fans worry merging the franchises may compromise Wolfenstein's serious themes.
As discussions continue, questions linger: Can humor coexist with serious narratives? Fans remain eager for answers as developers weigh potential paths for both beloved franchises.