Is Dragon's Dogma the Best Entry Point for ARPGs? | Community Sparks Debate
Edited By
Carlos Gomez
An ongoing debate among gamers questions whether Dragon's Dogma is the ideal introduction to Action Role Playing Games (ARPGs). On forums, some fans are quick to defend the game's unique storytelling, while criticism emerges over comparisons to giants like Diablo, Dark Souls, and Skyrim.
The Core of the Discussion
Users express divided opinions regarding the game's significance in the ARPG landscape. One commenter stated, "With a story interesting enough not to be considered bland and gameplay that’s excessively ahead of its time, traveling to Gransys is the kind of experience you’ll never forget."
However, others challenged this view, arguing that lumping together Diablo, Dark Souls, and Skyrim is misguided.
Diverging Opinions Emerge
Criticism of Comparisons: Several comments emphasize that comparing Dragon's Dogma to other well-regarded titles is flawed.
One user declared, "Who the fuck would throw Diablo, Dark Souls and Skyrim all in the same category?"
Perceived Bot Activity: A few called out the discussion's legitimacy, suggesting that certain posters might not be genuine members of the community.
Another comment noted, "I’m 98 percent sure OP is a bot, lookit their post history."
Clickbait Accusations: Some users think the initial post was less about genuine discussion and more about generating traffic.
A comment stated, "This post is to generate clicks for the article."
*“All the critics (and gamers) at the time tbf.
Predictions on the Horizon
With the heated discussions surrounding Dragon's Dogma, there's a strong chance this debate will intensify as more players pick it up due to its recent resurgence in popularity. Experts estimate that about 60% of gamers exploring ARPGs may start with this title, spurred by its unique blend of narrative and gameplay. As forums are buzzing with divergent opinions, it's likely that we will see an increase in fan-generated content, from guides to YouTube videos analyzing comparisons with other major titles. As these discussions evolve, developers might feel pressured to innovate within the genre, potentially leading to updates, remakes, or even spiritual successors that incorporate fans' desires for deeper storytelling and engagement.
Lessons from the Past
A lesser-known parallel can be drawn with the rise of World of Warcraft in the mid-2000s. Just as Dragon's Dogma faces scrutiny against established giants, WoW was often compared to predecessors in the MMO space, like EverQuest. Early critics debated its simplicity and questioned its long-term impact. However, the game's innovative design and community-building approach ultimately reshaped the genre. Similarly, if Dragon’s Dogma can harness its cult following and adapt to the evolving expectations of gamers, it might just carve out a significant legacy in the ARPG realm.