Home
/
Indie games
/
Indie game funding
/

The quest for an original superhero rpg: why not yet?

Why Haven't We Seen a Unique Superhero RPG Yet? | Fans Demand Originality

By

Sofia Zhang

May 2, 2025, 02:16 AM

Edited By

Sofia Wang

Snappy read

Concept art showing an original superhero character in a vibrant cityscape, ready to embark on adventures
popular

A growing chorus of gamers is voicing frustration over the lack of an original superhero RPG. Users are eager for a game that lets them craft their own superhero identities in a vibrant world, rather than relying on franchises like DC or Marvel. Despite the popularity of superhero media, no major studio has taken the plunge.

Context and Significance

Gamers are reminiscing about classics like City of Heroes, calling for a single-player experience that offers deep customization and storytelling. Comments reveal a mix of hope and skepticism about the frontiers of superhero gaming, highlighting a gap in the market that many feel could be filled.

Themes Emerging from the Discussion

  1. Limited Choices in Existing Games: Some gamers argue that titles like Infamous fail to provide the customization features players crave.

  2. Saturation of the Genre: Users mention the crowded superhero genre as a barrier to original titles, suggesting studios are hesitant to risk investment.

  3. Desire for Depth and Flexibility: The community longs for a more engaging RPG experience akin to modern titles but set in a superhero context.

Community Feedback

"In all seriousness, I kinda agree. The tropes make NPC interactions dull."

Another contributor noted that past games do not offer player agency:

"You played Desmond or whatever that lame guy's name was."

Yet, excitement remains:

"City of Heroes was so awesome. Itโ€™s bizarre that Marvel hasnโ€™t done this."

Sentiment Patterns

The overall tone appears to be a mix of nostalgia and frustration, as players remember past experiences while expressing disappointment at the industry's current direction.

Key Points to Remember

  • โ—พ Many gamers feel existing superhero games lack customization options.

  • โ–ฝ Infamous's last installment was nearly a decade ago, raising concerns about game development timelines.

  • โ€ป "Games take a long time to make; the superhero genre is saturated," as noted by one commenter.

As of now, the quest for an immersive, original superhero RPG continues. Will a bold studio finally answer this call? Only time will tell.