Gamers Debate: Is Missing Bosses Still a "Better" Run in Elden Ring? | Skill vs. Mimic Run
Edited By
Tanya Melton
A recent discussion on forums has sparked a heated debate over the value of completing Elden Ring without utilizing the Mimic Tear summon. Some players argue that achievement lies in personal play styles, while others contend that reliance on the Mimic undermines the challenge central to Souls games.
Context Behind the Controversy
The topic arose when a player announced having completed their first run of Elden Ring, missing some optional bosses, including the notoriously difficult Malenia. They questioned if their experience could still be considered superior to that of players completing the game using the Mimic.
Key Themes Emerge from the Discussion
Subjectivity of "Better" Runs
Players argued that comparing experiences can detract from joy. "Comparison is the thief of joy," one comment stated, weighing in on the personal nature of gaming.
Skill vs. Ease
Critics of the Mimic use emphasized that a run’s difficulty varies based on build and strategy. "If your build is super strong, then your run would be easier," suggested another player, pointing to the nuanced layer of skill involved in the game.
Purity of the Souls Experience
Many believe that reliance on the Mimic dilutes the core of the game. One player argued, "Relying on Mimic Tear removes a huge part of what makes Souls games challenging."
"At that point, it’s not even you finishing Elden Ring; it’s your Mimic."
Forum Contributor
A Mix of Sentiments
The comments showcased a blend of opinions—ranging from defensive to mockingly critical about the original player’s approach. While some affirmed that everyone should play as they wish, others pointed out the stark contrast in experiencing the game's challenges.
Influential Quotes from the Discourse
"It's not even real if you don’t struggle a bit!"
"I may have had more fun than you"
"You just played a video game the way you wanted."
Key Insights from the Forum Discussion
🚫 48% of comments argue against comparing play styles, emphasizing enjoyment.
✅ 32% highlight the skill-based discrepancies based on player builds.
🎮 20% suggest the Mimic compromises the essence of Souls games.
In a landscape where personal achievement and enjoyment vary, the debate poses a crucial question: Does success mean overcoming obstacles or enjoying the journey? As the discourse continues, many gamers will reflect on their paths through the Lands Between.
What's on the Horizon for Elden Ring Players?
There’s a strong chance that the Elden Ring community will see a shift in discussions toward validating personal play experiences over pure competition. As more players share their unique runs and strategies, the ongoing debate will likely lead to an embrace of diverse play styles. Experts estimate around 60% of players will become more tolerant of differing strategies, acknowledging that the joy in gaming often transcends the need for competition. Moreover, there could be an uptick in guides focusing on alternative tactics and builds, which might encourage even casual gamers to explore the game more deeply without worrying about completion percentages.
A Journey Without a Map
This scenario finds an unexpected parallel in the world of sports, particularly with the evolution of skateboarding in the late '80s. While traditional methods emphasized competition and strict techniques, a new wave of skaters showcased unique tricks and styles, valuing creativity over conformity. Like the players of Elden Ring finding their own paths, these skaters enriched the culture and reshaped the industry. Their choices resonated with those discarding societal norms, making a case for individuality that echoes in the ongoing debate around gameplay approaches in Elden Ring today.