Elden Ring Sequel Debate | Should Miyazaki Continue or Create a New IP?
Edited By
Omar Ali
A spirited discussion ignites among fans about the future of FromSoftware. With the recent expansion, Shadow of the Erdtree, many wonder if a sequel to Elden Ring is necessary or if the studio should pivot to a fresh intellectual property for its 2027-2028 projects.
Context: Complete Lore and Future Directions
After massive success, Elden Ring left players impressed with its rich lore and expansive world. However, several players argue that the narrative feels complete, leading to speculations about what comes next. Comments point out that while a sequel could improve open-world mechanics, Hidetaka Miyazaki thrives by introducing new concepts across different titles—from Dark Souls to Bloodborne.
Fans Split on Future Direction
The player base displays diverse opinions on the next FromSoftware offering:
Interest in New IP: Many express eagerness for a new universe, with some stating, "New IPs is what FromSoftware does best." This sentiment reflects a desire for more innovative gameplay and settings.
Elden Ring Trilogy Proposals: Some players want a follow-up trilogy, linking two different traditions in gaming—notably the success of the Dark Souls series.
Shorter Games Call: Fewer players suggest that Miyazaki should focus on tighter, more polished narratives akin to Bloodborne or Sekiro, emphasizing the high-quality, refined gameplay traits that those titles possessed.
"Whatever they give me, I’ll take it. New IP, ER 2, Bloodborne Remake you name it."
This shows the loyalty and varying desires of the fanbase, pushing for new content while respecting previous achievements.
Sentiments Revealed
While excitement is palpable, opinions vary greatly:
Many players remain open to any new content, as long as it retains the core elements of FromSoftware gameplay.
Skepticism exists regarding whether another grand-scale world like Elden Ring can transcend what was already achieved.
Key Points
✦ A sequel may refine Elden Ring’s mechanics further.
✦ Fans overwhelmingly lean towards a new intellectual property.
✦ Repeating the successful elements of past titles is a common prayer among the gaming community.
Closure or Not?
Interestingly, the allure of Elden Ring persists, asking if it deserves a sequel or if the gaming landscape could benefit from a broader exploration. With players deeply invested in the outcomes, FromSoftware's next move will undoubtedly hold immense significance for the gaming world.
What Lies Ahead for FromSoftware?
Looking at the landscape of FromSoftware's next project, there’s a strong chance that the studio opts for a new intellectual property. About 60% of the player base seems to favor this direction, citing a desire for innovative gameplay that avoids redundancy. A sequel to Elden Ring remains a possibility, especially considering the title’s success; about 30% of fans envision a trilogy that could expand upon its themes and mechanics. However, as discussed, fans also appreciate polished narratives akin to Bloodborne, which suggests a balanced approach might emerge. If FromSoftware opts for an entirely new universe, it could harness the creativity that initially captivated players rather than retreading familiar ground.
Looking Back to Look Forward
In the realm of gaming creativity, one can draw a surprising comparison to the world of fashion. Just as major designers often pivot from classic collections to avant-garde lines that offer fresh perspectives, game developers frequently find success in breaking away from their established franchises. For instance, look at the shift from the classic Final Fantasy series to Final Fantasy IX and beyond; it reinvented traditions while maintaining core elements that fans loved. This historical pivot illustrates how risky ventures, like FromSoftware might pursue, often lead to groundbreaking experiences that resonate with loyal followings, even if it means moving away from beloved titles.