Why Ellie Hesitated: The Theatre Scene Controversy | TLOU2 Fans Weigh In
Edited By
Marco Silva
In an intense scene from The Last of Us Part II, many fans are questioning why Ellie didn't pull the trigger on Abby while she had the chance. As Ellie confronts her rival in the theatre, a plethora of opinions surfaced online following a recent gameplay rewatch.
Context of the Scene
Fans of the game point to the moment where Ellie has an option to shoot Abby while Tommy's life hangs in the balance. With tension mounting, viewers are left pondering not just the plot choices but the survival instincts under intense pressure.
The Stakes in The Theatre
Multiple theories have emerged regarding Ellie’s inaction.
Abby’s Threat: "Abby had her gun aimed at Tommy. If Ellie shoots too soon, Tommy could get shot too." This assessment reflects a critical moment where every action could alter the outcome.
Lev’s Role: Commenters noted, "Lev has his bow pointed at her." This unseen factor complicates Ellie’s decision further, with fans acknowledging that Lev’s intervention could be immediate.
Potential Outcomes: Users brought up the idea that shooting Abby might not ensure Tommy’s safety: "Even a kill-shot on Abby could kill Tommy because Abby had her gun to Tommy’s head."
"If Ellie's plan is to get out of there with Tommy alive then there was no good shot."
This highlights the uncertainty and stakes involved in that split-second choice, where hesitation could lead to dire consequences.
Sentiments from the Community
While the discussion showcases mostly negative sentiments regarding Ellie’s hesitation, it also presents understanding of the complexity of such decisions in high-stakes situations. Some fans expressed regret about character outcomes by saying, "I don’t hate Abby, I just feel bad for Tommy getting permanently affected."
Key Insights
🔥 Tension in Decisions: The theatre encounter illustrates the high-stakes choices faced by characters.
🚨 Multiple Threats: Unseen threats such as Lev add complexity to decisions, reinforcing the uncertainty of survival.
🤔 Character Development: Some fans empathize with Ellie, acknowledging the emotional weight in her choices, like a real human instinct to hesitate in conflict.
As discussions continue, fans remain divided but engaged, wondering what could have happened if Ellie had acted differently. The emotional impact of TLOU2 continues to resonate deeply within its player base.