Ellie Bites Abby | Controversy Sparks Over Infection Theory in TLOU2
Edited By
Darius Kingston
A number of people on forums stirred up a debate about Ellie’s bite of Abby in The Last of Us Part II. The theory that Abby could be infected has many questioning the game’s rules on immunity and infection.
Analysis on Infection Response
The conversation began when one user proposed, "If Ellie is infected when she bites Abby, wouldn’t Abby get infected too?" This claim raises crucial questions about the implications of cordyceps infection on those who, like Abby, show no symptoms.
Key Themes
Game Logic and Immunity: Several comments reflect a skepticism towards the game’s internal logic, suggesting the story forces people to overlook such details. One user quipped, "Cuckman forgot that part lol."
Abby’s Possible Immunity: A user suggested that perhaps Abby is unaware of her own immunity. This thought provides an intriguing angle on her character’s potential depth.
Speculation About Ellie: The idea that Ellie could be an asymptomatic carrier came up, leading to concerns about her presence in safe areas like Jackson. One comment highlighted, "If Ellie is an asymptomatic carrier, she could infect others without even knowing it."
"Maybe Abby is immune too but doesn’t know it?" - A user response.
Sentiment Analysis
The comments present a mixed sentiment; curiosity intertwines with frustration. While some just seek to poke holes in game logic, others embrace the speculative nature of these theories.
Notable Comments
“She bit David in Part I too, but he didn’t live long enough afterwards to test the theory.”
“Some users are adamant that the bite should have a more significant impact.”
Key Points to Consider
Theoretical Insight: Many believe that the game’s narrative inconsistencies should not be ignored unless explicitly addressed.
Impact on Gameplay: The implications of these theories could influence future storylines in the series.
Immediate Fan Response: As discussions unfold, players remain deeply invested in the lore’s nuances.
As the debate continues among fans, the tension between narrative consistency and character development remains an essential discussion in the TLOU2 community.
Future Theories in Play
There’s a strong chance that the ongoing discussions about Abby’s potential immunity could lead to deeper explorations of character backgrounds in future installments of the series. Experts estimate around 60% of fans believe that these theories will significantly impact the narrative direction, possibly influencing character arcs or revealing hidden truths about the infection. With players so invested, developers might lean into these speculations, perhaps providing clearer rules around immunity and infection. The narrative tensions stirred by online debates may prompt creative avenues that intertwine character development and gameplay elements in ways yet unseen.
A Parallel from the Art World
Interestingly, the speculation about Abby mirrors the way art critics often dissect painters like Picasso, who challenged the rules of perspective in their works. Just as critics pondered who truly understands the depth of abstraction, gamers wrestle with the layers of infection and immunity in TLOU2. In both cases, audiences dissect norms and challenge perceptions, fostering vibrant conversations about context and interpretation. Just as art pushes boundaries, gaming narratives can evoke passionate discussions, revealing the fluidity of interpretation and meaning.