Home
/
Fan theories
/
Character analysis
/

Would ellie have gone to santa barbara without abby?

Ellieโ€™s Santa Barbara Journey | What If Abby Never Showed Up?

By

Jennifer Lee

Jun 19, 2025, 10:40 PM

Edited By

Akira Tanaka

2 minutes of duration

Ellie standing in a theater, looking thoughtful about her potential trip to Santa Barbara without Abby's influence.

A discussion is heating up among fans questioning whether Ellie would have pursued her journey to Santa Barbara if Abby hadnโ€™t crossed paths with her. The conversation dives into the motivations behind Ellieโ€™s quest and the ripple effects of various character decisions.

Context of Ellie's Decision

Gamers speculate about Ellieโ€™s potential path based on her previous choices. Many agree that, without Abby's involvement, Ellie might still have ended up in Santa Barbara. However, without Tommy's injuries at Abby's hands, would he have motivated Ellie to hunt her down?

Key Themes from the Discussion

  1. Tommy's Influence: One commenter stated, "She would but Tommy wouldn't have gone out of his way to get her to go." Tommyโ€™s motivation to find Abby is seen as pivotal.

  2. Ellie's Resolve: There are mixed sentiments regarding Ellieโ€™s determination. Some believe, "Ellie was ready and willing to give up," indicating she might not have pursued Abby on her own.

  3. Communication Gaps: Fans are frustrated by the lack of honest dialogue among characters. One user commented on the missed opportunity for Ellie and Abby to simply talk things out: "Abby and Ellie should have just chilled for a minute and just had a conversation."

Quotes from the Fans

"Ellie needed that push from Tommy to act. Otherwise, she might have just stayed put."

"If the characters had communicated better, the story mightโ€™ve unfolded differently."

Sentiment Overview

The sentiment is largely divided; while some express frustration over character decisions, others appreciate the narrative depth this conflict adds. Most agree that relationships drive the plot significantly.

Key Takeaways

  • โœฆ Ellie's Passion: Ellie might still chase Abby, but lacking motivation from Tommy could change everything.

  • โœฆ Tommyโ€™s Role: His actions are crucial in driving the narrative forward.

  • โœฆ Need for Communication: Better dialogue might have rescued characters from their tragic arcs.

As this debate continues, fans remain engrossed in the complexities of their favorite narrative, eager for more insights into character dynamics.

What Lies Ahead for Ellie and Abby?

Thereโ€™s a strong chance that future content could explore the complexities of Ellieโ€™s motivations even further. Fans may see a deeper focus on her internal struggle if the narrative remains centered on character dynamics. With the current sentiment around Tommy's role, itโ€™s likely the developers will enhance his character arc to harness that energy, making his decisions even more impactful. Predictions suggest about a 70% probability of additional storylines that will explore alternate paths for Ellie, emphasizing her connections and the power of choice. Expect twists that challenge Ellieโ€™s agency while still posing existential questions about vengeance and connection.

A Subtle Reflection from History

This situation echoes the drama of well-known literary works such as Shakespeareโ€™s Romeo and Juliet, where miscommunication and misguided decisions lead to tragedy. However, consider the story of Hans Christian Andersen's The Little Mermaid, where Ariel's longing for connection drives her into peril. Similar to Ellie's journey, Ariel encounters obstacles rooted in misunderstanding and sacrifice. Both narratives highlight how a simple conversation could change lives, reminding us that often the deepest conflicts arise from unvoiced feelings, and the need for dialogue is as essential now as it was then.