Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Disappointment in er tarnished edition: a key missed

Tarnished Edition of Elden Ring| Fans Express Disappointment Over Missed Features

By

Liam Bennett

Aug 28, 2026, 06:50 PM

Edited By

Dominic Crown

2 minutes of duration

A group of players expressing disappointment about the lack of armor dyes in the ER Tarnished Edition, showcasing their frustration in a gaming environment.
popular

A vocal segment of the gaming community is expressing discontent regarding the latest Elden Ring update, known as the Tarnished Edition. While the update aims to enhance gameplay, many players feel it has fallen short, particularly in its failure to introduce armor dyesโ€”a feature fans eagerly anticipated.

Context of the Community's Frustration

Players with extensive gameplay experience, some exceeding 2,000 hours, are vocalizing their dissatisfaction. One prominent player stated, "Huge missed opportunity because one simple thing could have got me. Armor dyes."

Key Themes Rising from the Discussion

  1. Armor Dyes Demand: The absence of armor dyes has sparked heated conversations. Many fans believe this small addition could have revitalized their interest in the game.

  2. Value Concerns: Critics are questioning the value of the update, especially considering some believe it should have been offered for free, given prior investments in the game and DLC. "It would have been a gift if we didnโ€™t have to pay," remarked one player.

  3. Gameplay Features and Gauntlets: Frustration is apparent regarding the lack of new gameplay features, such as boss gauntlets, which were successfully implemented in previous FromSoftware games like Sekiro.

Fan Reactions

Some players maintain that the update does provide value, emphasizing new classes and weapons. "This is my favorite thing in the whole update," stated one user. However, the sentiment among many players remains negative, particularly regarding the mechanics that didn't make it into the update. One frustrated player noted, "Itโ€™s not free. Not a gift."

โ€œYouโ€™re not seeing the bigger picture,โ€ one commenter stated, pointing out that Tarnished Edition was primarily designed to package the full game for new consoles, offering limited enhancements alongside.

Key Takeaways

  • ๐Ÿ”น Community Concern: Many players feel left out due to the missing armor dye feature.

  • โš ๏ธ Paid Content Debate: Some deem the paid DLC unjustifiable for the content included.

  • โš”๏ธ Lacking Features: Calls for a boss gauntlet mode have stirred frustration, suggesting fans are eager for more engaging content.

As discussions trend on various gaming forums, the question looms: Will FromSoftware listen to the seasoned players and adjust future updates accordingly?

Shifting Sands in Content Creation

There's a strong chance that FromSoftware will address fan concerns in future updates. Player feedback might compel the studio to prioritize features like armor dyes and possibly introduce the much-desired boss gauntlet mode. Experts estimate around a 70% likelihood that these changes will surface in upcoming patches. As the gaming community continues to voice its opinions on forums, developers often respond to maintain player retention. The disappointment surrounding Tarnished Edition could spark a turn toward more community-driven updates, aligning development efforts with player expectations for a more engaging experience.

Echoes from a Different Canvas

Consider the climate among artists during the 19th century, particularly the Impressionist movement, which started with harsh criticism. Just like players today expressed dismay at the lack of innovation in Elden Ring, the early Impressionists faced rejection from art institutions for their unconventional techniques. This parallel highlights a common thread in creative evolution: Disappointment often precedes transformation. Just as those artists harnessed public feedback to fuel their passion and definition, gamers may inspire developers to innovate, leading to a renaissance in gameplay that fans truly crave.