Gamers Debate Which Iconic Weapon Should Return | Insights from the Community
Edited By
Emily Johnson
A heated discussion has erupted among gamers regarding which weapon should make a comeback in future titles from the creators of Lies of P. The debate gained traction on user boards, with many offering passionate arguments and suggestions on January 27, 2026.
Context of the Discussion
Gamers are eager to see iconic weapons reappear in upcoming games. This trend is common in gaming, often allowing players to connect with familiar elements. The moonlight greatsword is frequently cited from FromSoftware titles, leading fans to ponder its counterpart in Lies of P.
Popular Suggestions from Gamers
Three main themes emerged from the comments:
Iconic Weapons
The Puppet Saber surfaced as a frontrunner, with one player remarking, "This would probably be the one they’d do".
Other favored choices include the Monad Rose Sword and Pale Knight, emphasizing their significance in gameplay.
Community Favorites
Players expressed fondness for the Trident of the Covenant and Dragon Glaive, highlighting their effectiveness during gameplay.
A player admired the Frozen Feast, stating, "LoP might just be my favorite not only 'souls-like' but favorite game of this genre."
Unique Perspectives
Creative ideas emerged, like the Proof of Humanity, which one commenter predicted might align with character arcs: "Dorothy's would probably be an emerald sword."
The notion of tying weapons to character stories adds a deeper layer to their significance.
Sentiment Overview
The overall sentiment on the user boards appears positive, with players passionately engaging in the discussion. Enthusiasm for returning weapons suggests a desire for continuity as well as innovation in future titles.
Key Highlights
🔱 Puppet Saber is considered a prime candidate for a returning weapon.
⚔️ Monad Rose Sword and Pale Knight have strong support based on their in-game significance.
💬 "LoP might just be my favorite not only 'souls-like,' but favorite game of this genre," reflects the strong emotional connection to these weapons.
That’s the latest from the gaming community on iconic weapons. Which one would you choose to see make a comeback?
What’s on the Horizon?
As Lies of P continues to engage its community, there’s a strong chance we may see some of the currently popular weapons making a reappearance in future titles. Given the excitement from players over choices like the Puppet Saber and Monad Rose Sword, developers might consider integrating fan favorites into upcoming games. Experts estimate a likelihood of about 70% for at least one of these iconic weapons to show up, as the demand for player nostalgia can significantly influence development decisions. This trend will likely not only sustain the current player base but also draw in new players yearning for innovative gameplay with familiar elements.
Echoes from the Past
Reflecting on the community's fervor, one can draw parallels to the revival of classic music hits in modern pop culture. Just as artists reinvent timeless tracks to create fresh experiences for new audiences, game developers similarly resurrect beloved weapons to resonate with both returning players and newcomers. This borrowing from previous successes plays a critical role in the ongoing evolution of both music and gaming, where familiar hooks or mechanics deliver comfort while embracing innovation. The dialogue surrounding iconic weapons embodies not just a desire for nostalgia but a collective hope that the upcoming titles will honor the history of the franchise while pushing creative boundaries.