Home
/
Gaming news
/
Game reviews
/

Why this extraction shooter is struggling to survive

Marathon | Got Players Dropping Faster Than Ever

By

Leila Akhtar

Jul 7, 2026, 05:46 PM

3 minutes of duration

A player character in tactical gear aiming a weapon in a war-torn environment, showcasing limited gear and intense action.
popular

A growing concern surrounds Bungie's latest extraction shooter, Marathon, as players abandon the game at an alarming rate. Many cite the lack of unique gameplay and insufficient incentives for progression as major factors contributing to its decline.

The discourse on various forums highlights that the real failure of the game isn't its difficulty; itโ€™s how the gameplay direction and core systems have failed to engage and retain players. While some argue that challenging gameplay can drive engagement, Marathon's unique blend of mechanics appears to frustrate players instead. Reports indicate that the main issues reside in three key areas: gear variety, class customization, and progression systems.

Key Issues Lurking Beneath the Surface

Gear Variety: A Disappointing Arsenal

Players have expressed disappointment with the weapon selection. Many feel that the majority of available gear is ineffective, leading to a lack of motivation to experiment with different loadouts. A player mentioned, "The game is unrewarding the rich get richer, and new players canโ€™t break through the glass ceiling."

Class Customization: Missed Opportunities

The gameโ€™s shell system, designed for character customization, underwhelms many players. Critics argue that it fundamentally clashes with the long-term investment required in an extraction shooter. One user opined, "You canโ€™t retain players with a system that actively works against progression." The desire to customize and craft unique strategies is stifled, leading to a stagnant gaming experience.

Progression: Why Bother?

Frustration peaks with the gameโ€™s vendor unlock system, seen by many as inadequate. As one user succinctly stated, "What are we really doing this for?" Players found it hard to remain motivated when goals feel irrelevant. Thereโ€™s insufficient long-term progression to entice most players to keep grinding.

Community Sentiment: A Mix of Frustration and Loyalty

The community seems divided between those who enjoy the game's mechanics and those who feel betrayed by its perceived shortcomings. "Iโ€™m back to competitive shooters for now," admitted one dedicated player with over 600 hours logged, highlighting the struggles many face.

Interestingly, some players attribute the decline to a lack of fresh interest despite initial sales, which indicates that many are dropping out rather than sticking around. One comment stands out: "The game is just too small; once a meta is set, you either use it or fail."

Key Takeaways

  • ๐Ÿ”ฅ User feedback suggests the gear system is uninspiring, leading to a lack of variety.

  • ๐Ÿ’” Players express dissatisfaction with the class customization options.

  • ๐Ÿ“‰ Progression systems fail to keep engagement high, raising questions on game longevity.

Bungieโ€™s extraction shooter seems to be losing steam, with calls for a free-to-play model in hopes of reviving its player base. As some contend, addressing the core issues is critical for maintaining engagement. But with the gameโ€™s reputation fluctuating, can Bungie turn things around or has it already invested too heavily in the wrong direction?

What Lies Ahead for Marathon?

Thereโ€™s a strong chance Bungie may pivot towards a free-to-play model as they attempt to rescue Marathon from its decline. Experts estimate thereโ€™s around a 60% probability that the introduction of such a model could attract new players and rekindle interest among those who have left. This pivot would likely need to be accompanied by significant updates addressing the core issues, especially in the areas of gear diversity and progression systems. If Bungie can effectively revamp its offerings, it could stabilize and possibly grow the player base, although thereโ€™s also a 40% risk they may not recapture the original audience, who might move on permanently to competing titles.

A Lesson from the Grunge Era

The situation with Marathon mirrors the rise and fall of grunge music in the 90s. Initially, bands like Nirvana and Pearl Jam captivated audiences, but once the novelty wore off, many fans felt the genre had nowhere else to go. With repetitive sounds and a lackluster approach to creativity, interest dwindled. Just as music fans sought fresh sounds and innovation, gamers may very well turn away from Marathon if it doesnโ€™t offer new engagement avenues. This parallel underscores the importance of constant evolution in both gaming and music, demonstrating that stagnation can lead to loss of passion and loyalty.