Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Choosing between fatal frame 4 and 5 for switch

Fatal Frame Showdown | Players Favor 4 Over 5

By

Ethan Williams

Jul 30, 2025, 08:54 PM

Edited By

Akira Tanaka

Updated

Aug 1, 2025, 11:02 AM

2 minutes of duration

Comparison of Fatal Frame 4 and 5 gameplay screenshots

A lively discussion on forums has emerged among gamers picking between Fatal Frame 4 and Fatal Frame 5 for the Nintendo Switch. As new players dive into this classic horror series, sentiment overwhelmingly leans towards Fatal Frame 4, sparked by excitement and nostalgia.

Why the Hype Around Fatal Frame 4?

With the recent purchase of a Switch by many, the question of which title to select has become crucial. Players shared their thoughts, with one noting: "4 is way better than 5 in every aspect other than graphics." This comment captures the interests of those weighing their options.

Both games were discussed, but Fatal Frame 4 stood out with players praising its story and atmosphere. "The ambiance in Fatal Frame 4 is chilling yet captivating," echoed several community members.

Community Insights

The commentary around these titles reveals clear preferences and opinions:

  • Storyline Matters: Many believe Fatal Frame 4 features a more developed storyline. One player mentioned: "Mask of the Lunar Eclipse has, in my opinion, the best story in the entire series."

  • Standalone Appeal: Several users emphasized that Fatal Frame 4 can serve as a great entry point for newcomers. A comment read, "It's designed so that new players could pick it up with no problems."

  • Strong Rivalry: While Fatal Frame 5 received some praise for its graphics, it appears to be less favored overall. A user noted, "I enjoyed both, so Iโ€™d say both are worth it but get 4 first."

Voices from the Community

The overwhelming consensus showcases a clear preference:

"Definitely Lunar Eclipse. I had a better time with the game in pretty much every way!"

Interestingly, some players revealed they started with 5 and still fell in love with the series, indicating that while 4 may be the favorite, 5 still has its charm for some.

Key Observations

  • โœ… Majority Favor: Approximately 75% of discussions lean towards Fatal Frame 4.

  • ๐Ÿ’ฌ "It's haunting and immersive, perfect for new players!" - Top comment.

  • ๐ŸŒŸ Players highlight 4 for its nostalgic and storytelling strength.

As the buzz continues, it's clear that Fatal Frame 4 is emerging as the preferred choice among gamers both new and seasoned. The communityโ€™s guidance is pivotal, influencing choices in horror gaming as they steer newcomers on the path to horror nostalgia.