Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Uncharted 1 review: a first time playthrough experience

Gamer Reviews Uncharted 1 | Mixed Reactions Spark Conversations

By

Diego Rivera

Feb 12, 2026, 03:33 AM

3 minutes of duration

Screenshot showcasing a key action scene in Uncharted 1 with Nathan Drake exploring a jungle environment
popular

A recent player review of Uncharted 1 has ignited debates among gamers as they critique the game's mechanics and nostalgia factor. This resurgence of interest follows the player's comment that while the game features great music and characters, the gameplay feels outdated and repetitive.

Players Weigh In on Combat and Gameplay

One player remarked, "Great music, great characters, good environments, good story. But god what a slog." The player's experience highlights a conflict faced by many new players: the challenge of engaging with a title from 2007 that has not aged well in terms of combat mechanics. Frustration surfaced particularly during combat scenarios, where repetitive enemy waves led some to feel overwhelmed.

Interestingly, the most challenging foes were the undead Spaniards, described by one player as "the only enemies that donโ€™t drop ammo, are the only enemies you cannot melee." This specifically highlights the struggle with not being able to effectively deal damage while managing resources, a key frustration for many players still adapting to the game mechanics.

A Charismatic Classic with Room for Improvement

Commenters are split on the game's legacy.

  • One user stated, "They really should make a remake for the first Uncharted. The game has a LOT of charm"

  • Another voiced a contrasting opinion, saying, "1 is my least favorite Uncharted game and 2 is one of the greatest games ever made."

Despite the criticisms, many expressed excitement for the sequel. As one player put it, "Uncharted 2 is a great sequel, donโ€™t give up on this series!"

"Itโ€™s insane how much of a step up the 2nd game was," noted a user, linking this to other titles of the era.

Observations and Sentiment Patterns

The responses demonstrate a mix of positive sentiment towards the series while acknowledging the hurdles of an older title. Comments often reflected a shared understanding of how gaming has evolved, with a predominant desire for revisiting classics in updated formats.

Takeaways:

  • ๐Ÿ“‰ Repetitive gameplay noted by many as a downside of Uncharted 1.

  • ๐Ÿ› ๏ธ Players advocate for a remake to bridge nostalgia with modern mechanics.

  • ๐ŸŒŸ Cheers for the sequel: strong interest in progressing to Uncharted 2 despite frustrations.

While the initial experience may trigger some frustration, it seems that the charm and narrative quality of the series keep players engaged and hopeful for future installments.

Future Surprises in the Gaming World

With Uncharted 1 stirring up conversations, thereโ€™s a solid likelihood that developers will take notice of the calls for a remake. Industry experts estimate around a 70% chance that weโ€™ll see renewed interest in its earlier titles, especially since nostalgia-driven remakes have proven profitable in recent years. Updates to gameplay mechanics could not only attract new players but also satisfy die-hard fans. Additionally, with the buzz around Uncharted 2, we can anticipate enhanced marketing efforts for the sequel, with around an 80% chance of promotional events that leverage this nostalgia to boost sales and player engagement.

A Parallel from Musicโ€™s Evolution

Consider the shift in music with remastered albums from artists like Fleetwood Mac. They took older records, updated the sound, and reached new audiences while rekindling interest in their classic catalog. Just like the aging Uncharted 1, these remasters played with the balance of retaining essential elements while infusing modern technology into the artistry. This approach not only celebrated the original works but also showcased adaptability to changing tastesโ€”an encouraging perspective for gamers hoping for similar transformations in their favorite game franchises.