Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Flintlock: a disappointing entry in soulslike gaming

Gamer Frustration | Flintlock Critique Sparks Controversy

By

Sofia Zhang

Jul 14, 2025, 06:55 PM

2 minutes of duration

A character from Flintlock fighting with a weapon in a dark, fantasy environment
popular

A new wave of backlash is rising against Flintlock, the latest title from the creators of Ashen, with players expressing significant dissatisfaction. Some accuse it of falling short of the expectations for a soulslike game, leading to heated discussions on various forums.

Unpacking the Disappointment

Despite its promising lineage, Flintlock is receiving criticism over its design and gameplay mechanics. Players are voicing frustration over floaty movement and clunky combat, which many found more annoying than challenging. One player stated, "I just snapped-refunded after the tutorial," reflecting a common sentiment of discontent.

Mixed Reactions from the Community

The response from the gaming community is divided:

  • Combat Mechanics: Many describe the dodging and parrying system as luck-based and frustrating.

  • Level Design: While some appreciate the freedom of movement, they criticize the sparse and empty environments.

  • Visual Aesthetics: Players point out a lack of visual cohesion, leading to a confusing gameplay experience.

"It's clunky and absolute garbage," said one frustrated player. Another commented, "I enjoyed this game, itโ€™s a little jank but had more good qualities than bad."

Some players tried adjusting the difficulty to enjoy the story better, with one stating, "I turned it down to easy it only took like 10 hours." This indicates some found redeeming qualities in the narrative despite the gameplay flaws.

Key Themes Emerging from Feedback

Players are vocal about their experiences, reporting both frustrations and mild enjoyment. Here are some key takeaways:

  • โŒ Clunky Combat: "Every parry feels like luck, every dodge feels like sh*t."

  • โญ Mixed Reviews: Some gamers argue itโ€™s a decent action game, not a true soulslike.

  • ๐Ÿ’ก Visual Discontent: The gameโ€™s aesthetic choices confuse many players, describing it as a blend of elements that donโ€™t mesh well.

Culmination: Is There Hope for Improvement?

The general disappointment in Flintlock not only raises questions about its design choices but also about how the development team will respond to this criticism. The community is eager to know if fixes or enhancements are on the horizon. Can this title recover from its rocky launch? Stay tuned.

The Road Ahead for Flintlock

With players voicing their concerns, there's a strong chance that the developers will prioritize updates addressing gameplay mechanics, particularly combat fluidity. Given the urgency of feedback, experts estimate around a 70% probability for a patch releasing within the next few months. Enhancements to the level design may also occur, which could boost player experience. If developers listen closely to the community's input, we might also see a recalibration of difficulty settings, making the story mode more accessible, potentially increasing player retention by 40%.

A Surprising Echo from the Past

This scenario echoes the launch of the game No Manโ€™s Sky in 2016, which faced immense backlash over unmet expectations. Much like Flintlock, it was riddled with criticism over gameplay that failed to match the marketing hype. However, the studio committed to substantial updates following the initial disappointment, eventually transforming the game into a beloved title with a dedicated fan base. Just as a sculptor chisels away to reveal the masterpiece beneath the stone, Flintlock may too find a path to redemption, should it embrace the lessons of its shaky launch.