Home
/
AAA games
/
Game expansions
/

Struggling with game choices: dlc or elden ring?

Should Gamers Invest in DLC or Shift to Elden Ring? | A Tough Call

By

Jennifer Lee

Jan 5, 2026, 04:24 AM

Edited By

Clara Evers

3 minutes of duration

A gamer sitting in front of a screen, contemplating whether to buy DLC or play Elden Ring, with game boxes on the desk
popular

Preamble: What Players Are Saying

As discussions heat up in various forums, players grapple with the dilemma of investing in downloadable content (DLC) versus venturing into a new game. The latest chatter focuses on two titles: the recently completed Lies of P and the highly anticipated Elden Ring.

The Dilemma: DLC vs. New Adventures

Gamers are at a crossroads. One player recently posed the question, weighing the purchase of the Lies of P DLC against buying Elden Ring instead. The online community has been buzzing with opinions. Many fans suggest opting for Elden Ring, spotlighting the game's vast content and replayability.

Community Insights: The Vote Favors Elden Ring

Several notable comments in user boards reflect a consensus around this choice:

  1. More Hours, More Fun: One player stated, "You will get more hours played from Elden Ring for sure." With players reporting around 100 hours on their first blind playthrough in Elden Ring, it's clear that the game packs a significant amount of gameplay.

  2. Confidence in Content: Another community member emphasized, "Elden Ring is several times more content and an excellent game," reinforcing the sentiment that the new title offers more value than the DLC.

  3. Future Considerations: A player suggested, "Get the Elden Ring, get the DLC later when itโ€™s on discount," indicating a potential strategy for budget-conscious gamers looking to enjoy both experiences without breaking the bank.

"Elden Ring is arguably game of the decade," remarked one enthusiast, highlighting its critical acclaim.

Analyzing the Sentiment: The Power of Choice

The sentiment trends heavily towards Elden Ring in this discourse, with many gamers prioritizing newer content over minor expansions of already completed games. The discussions display a blend of excitement and strategic planning, revealing how the gaming audience values time and money in their gaming experiences.

Key Takeaways

  • ๐Ÿ”„ Majority Lean Toward New Titles: Players generally favor Elden Ring for its extensive gameplay.

  • โณ Time Investment: First plays of Elden Ring average about 100 hours, while the Lies of P DLC caps around 20 hours.

  • ๐Ÿ’ฌ Community's Advice: Save the DLC purchase for a sale to maximize gaming enjoyment.

Navigating the Future of Game Choices

Experts estimate there's a strong chance that the momentum behind Elden Ring will persist as players continue to favor fresh content over DLC expansions. With many players confirming the engaging and lengthy gameplay of Elden Ring, this could drive increased sales, with predictions suggesting a potential 30% rise in purchases over the next few months. Conversely, the Lies of P DLC may see slower sales, with some gamers opting to wait for discounts, reflecting a shift in prioritization towards bigger gaming experiences over minor enhancements. As developers notice these trends, we could also see more substantial updates or sequels to popular titles to capture this appetite for expansive gameplay.

A Unique Lens on Gaming Choices

Looking back at the switch from VHS to DVD in the early 2000s provides an interesting framework to understand current gaming trends. Just as consumers initially grappled with whether to enhance their VHS libraries with cheaper tapes or move towards the new format leveraging better quality and features, gamers today face similar choices. Those who embraced the new technology not only enjoyed superior experiences but also positioned themselves for future advancements, a parallel that resonates with todayโ€™s gamers deciding between investing in DLC versus immersing themselves in expansive games like Elden Ring. This evolution in preferences showcases an enduring quest for improvement and satisfaction, reflecting how technology and content shape consumer behavior across eras.