Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Player disappointed after finishing game in 24 hours

Gamers Dismayed by Quick Completion of Elden Ring Content | Expectations vs Reality

By

Maximilian Schubert

Aug 20, 2026, 12:48 AM

Edited By

Clara Evers

2 minutes of duration

A gamer sits in front of a computer, looking frustrated with a game controller in hand, surrounded by game achievements on the screen.
popular

Mixed Reactions Erupt Over Game Length

A recent comment on a popular forum sparked a firestorm of opinions as one player claimed to finish Elden Ring in just 24 hours. Many players argue that this quick playthrough reveals a deeper issue regarding content accessibility versus casual play style.

The Backlash Begins

The original poster expressed disappointment, stating, "I know there's more there but I didn't expect to fly through it this quick." This stirred up responses ranging from sympathy to outright criticism. Users chimed in, questioning the value of skipping optional content, with one remarking, "You skipped all the optional content. You're a special breed."

Key Themes in the Comments

  1. Critique of Gameplay Style

    Many comments highlight the dissatisfaction with the player's approach, suggesting that following a guide detracted from the experience, like one user stated, "to play Elden Ring following a guide your first time is just sad."

  2. Content Depth Ignored

    Several commenters noted that players may not understand the gameโ€™s true depth if they only focus on achievements. As one replied, "Youโ€™ve played a little less than half of what your game has to offer."

  3. Tone of Skepticism

    Comments are mixed, with users expressing whether the original post was genuine or meant to provoke. One sarcastic comment read, "This is either ragebait or one of the dumber posts Iโ€™ve seen on here."

"This guy has never played Elden Ring," noted another user, highlighting the divide in player experiences.

Sentiment Check

The overall sentiment appears to be skewed towards disbelief and critique. Responses lean heavily on questioning the player's methods while defending the richness of the game.

Key Takeaways

  • โ–ณ 24 hours to complete Elden Ring is widely considered too short for its depth.

  • โ–ฝ Optional content is crucial for a fuller experience; many users suggest avoiding guides.

  • โ€ป "Man just enjoy the game" - A call to embrace exploration.

The Gaming Community's Call to Action

As discussions unfold, one essential question remains: Are casual gamers missing out on the true magic of Elden Ring? With the community voicing various perspectives, it might be time for players to rethink how they approach their gaming adventures in 2026.

What Lies Ahead for Gamers

There's a strong chance that discussions around game completion times will continue to intensify within the gaming community. As casual gamers become more prevalent, content creators might start producing guides that prioritize speed over total immersion. Experts estimate that around 60% of newcomers to the gaming scene could adopt walkthroughs, inadvertently missing out on nuanced narratives and side quests. This trend could lead developers to reevaluate their content structures, possibly shifting toward alternatives that encourage exploration and deeper engagement, as players might demand longer gameplay to feel satisfied with their experiences.

Echoes from history

In a way, this gaming discourse reminds us of the early days of film; audiences seeking instant gratification often overlooked the storytelling nuances crafted by directors. Just as some viewers rushed through montages to reach the climax, many players today opt for rapid completion over the intricate tales woven in games like Elden Ring. The cinematic evolution taught us that depth can yield lasting impact, prompting thoughtful appreciation rather than fleeting enjoyment. As gamers reflect on their experiences, a similar appreciation for patience and depth may well emerge, reshaping how future titles are designed and played.