Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Ghost of tsushima: overrated, underrated, or just right?

Ghost of Tsushima | Ratings Debate as Ghost of Yotei Release Approaches

By

Sana Abdul-Jabbar

Sep 19, 2025, 12:21 PM

Edited By

Samir Patel

3 minutes of duration

A dramatic scene from Ghost of Tsushima showcasing the protagonist, Jin, in a lush Japanese landscape with a samurai stance
popular

A vibrant discussion is heating up within gaming forums as fans reflect on Ghost of Tsushima ahead of its sequel, Ghost of Yotei. With varied opinions on whether the original game deserves its acclaim, players are sharing thoughts just two weeks before the highly anticipated launch.

What the Fans Are Saying

The original game has earned a strong following, placing Jin Sakai among the notable protagonists in gaming history. Many players appreciate the combat and art style, ranking it among the top tier on the PS4. However, the reception isnโ€™t unanimous.

Comments reveal differing views on the gameโ€™s merit. One player pointed out, "It feels like a 85-87, but the user score is a 9.2", indicating a divide between critical and user perspectives. Another stated, "It's certainly better than the average Ubisoft open world game but it doesn't do anything to reinvent the wheel." This statement reflects a belief that while enjoyable, it failed to push boundaries in gaming design.

Key Themes Emerge

Quality of Gameplay

Many players praise the game's combat mechanics. A commenter noted, "The combat in Ghost of Tsushima is a dance when youโ€™re chaining moves right." This is echoed across several reviews, pointing to the engaging nature of gameplay that players find captivating.

Story and Character Depth

Critics argue the story lacks depth, with one remarking, "Itโ€™s basically an Assassins Creed game with a less interesting story." Another player expressed disappointment in the character arcs, suggesting they didnโ€™t connect on a meaningful level.

Critical vs. User Ratings

The disparity between critic and user ratings has sparked conversation. One user highlighted that reviewers may have been influenced by deadlines: "Reviewers crammed the game in a short span which made them enjoy it less." This observation raises questions about how review conditions can affect perceptions of quality.

Sentiments in the Community

Responses display a mix of positive and critical sentiments, with many players expressing clear preferences. While some view it as underrated, others accuse it of being overrated. This back-and-forth underscores ongoing debates in the gaming community.

Key Insights

  • โ–ณ Player ratings indicate strong loyalty, with a high user score of 9.2.

  • โ–ฝ Critics seem divided; some view it as a run-of-the-mill open-world game.

  • โ€ป "I didnโ€™t feel like I was surprised at any point," highlights the argument for more innovation in narratives.

In the run-up to Ghost of Yotei's release, itโ€™s clear that Ghost of Tsushima remains a polarizing title, fueling excitement as well as debate among its dedicated fan base. Players await to see how the sequel matches up to its predecessor, and whether it can bridge the gap identified in opinions.

Eyes on the Horizon

Thereโ€™s a strong chance that Ghost of Yotei will draw both the loyal fans of its predecessor and new players intrigued by the promise of an enriched gaming experience. Experts estimate around a 70% likelihood that the sequel will address some criticisms, particularly around story depth and innovation, as developers have acknowledged community feedback. Moreover, with the rise of streaming platforms, players might witness a more vibrant discussion online, potentially raising the profile of both games further as they engage with the active gaming community. This anticipation can reshape the conversation surrounding sequels, ultimately helping the franchise cultivate a stronger identity.

Echoes from the Past

Reflecting on the situation brings to mind the launch of the Final Fantasy VII Remake. Initially met with mixed reactions regarding its departure from original gameplay mechanics, it eventually turned into a discussion about expectations versus reality in game design. Just like now with Ghost of Tsushima, some fans lamented the changes while others embraced them, creating a buzz that made the game even more popular. This unexpected outcome reminds us how evolving conversations within gaming communities can transform perceptions and drive interest, making history repeat itself in the most intriguing ways.