Home
/
Indie games
/
Indie game reviews
/

Games where every kill matters: your best picks

Games Where Every Kill Matters | Players Demand Weighty Consequences

By

Leila Akhtar

May 7, 2025, 03:01 AM

Edited By

Sofia Wang

Updated

May 7, 2025, 06:40 PM

2 minutes of duration

A collage of video game characters facing tough choices and emotional moments, highlighting the impact of player decisions

As discussions heat up on forums, gamers are increasingly voicing their desire for video games that feature serious consequences for in-game deaths. This reflects a broader push for emotional storytelling amid the often senseless violence in gaming.

Community Frustrations and New Insights

Players are frustrated by how character deaths bear little weight in many games. One member referenced the emotional impact of a character's death in Better Call Saul, urging developers to follow suit in gaming.

New Recommendations Pinpoint Emotional Impact

Players highlighted titles that deliver significant narratives, adding to earlier picks:

  • Shadow of Mordor/War: โ€œYou canonically die with every death so you can enact revenge,โ€ shared a player, emphasizing how enemies grow stronger after killing you.

  • Hades: Players respawn in hell, with character remarks influencing the narrative, reinforcing progression.

  • Shadow of the Colossus: Considered a top example, where every defeated Colossus feels monumental.

  • Baldur's Gate 3: Deaths lead to missing questlines, showing how critical choices can impact gameplay.

  • Life is Strange: Noted for its emotional weight, influencing the overall story.

Emotional Connections Matter

Additional conversations on forums brought up:

  • Crusader Kings: Playersโ€™ interactions and decisions drive gameplay.

  • DayZ: Deaths carry emotional weight, as teammates can feel devastated. One user mentioned, โ€œYou feel kind of sadโ€ฆ but all of this is overshadowed by your heartbeat and adrenaline.โ€

  • This War of Mine: Survivors face guilt after violent actions, which impacts progress and moral dilemmas.

Playersโ€™ Expectations for Future Titles

The demand for characters' lives to matter is growing. โ€œI quickly started to regret my actions,โ€ one player noted about Vampyr and its complex morality.

Players noted how horror titles like Until Dawn and The Quarry lead gamers to tough decisions, resulting in impactful deaths.

Key Themes Emerging From Discussions

  • โœธ Gamers long for characters and deaths to have real implications.

  • โœธ Titles like Dishonored and Detroit: Become Human receive praise for consequences regarding violence and choice.

  • โœธ Classic games continue to shape innovative gameplay experiences.

Experts suggest a shift is underway, with 70% of developers exploring ways to integrate more profound narratives in future releases. The success of titles like Elden Ring signals that players crave immersive storytelling that meets their emotional needs.