Home
/
Fan theories
/
Character analysis
/

Joe keery's charm could suit nathan's role perfectly

Joe Keery Sparks Debate Over Nathan Drake Casting | Fans Revisit Character Choices

By

Oliver Martinez

Feb 16, 2026, 03:47 PM

Edited By

Tanya Melton

2 minutes of duration

Joe Keery shows off his charm with a bright smile while wearing a casual shirt, capturing the attention of fans with his appeal.
popular

A recent discussion about Nathan Drake's casting in the Uncharted film series has reignited interest among fans. Many believe Joe Keery would have made a fitting choice for the role, even if he doesn't match the character's appearance perfectly.

Keery's charisma, stemming from his notable performance in Stranger Things, caught the attention of many users on forums. One highlighted his allure by stating, "He has this effortless sort of charm/charisma which seems really Nathan-like." This statement garnered significant support, highlighting a desire for a different actor in the lead role of Nathan Drake.

Fans Weigh In on Casting Dynamics

Amid the significant voices in the debate, evidence suggests a mixed sentiment towards Tom Holland's portrayal of young Nathan Drake.

Comments Reveal Divided Opinions

  • Support for Keery: "He would make an even better young Han Solo," argued one commenter, showcasing how versatile the actor could be.

  • Tom Holland's Performance: Another user remarked, "Honestly, Tom wasnโ€™t a terrible choice but there were so many more problems with that movie."

  • Age Perception: Some commenters noted Keery looks younger than Drake. One stated, "He looks like Nate in his early twenties," reflecting the different perceptions of age in character casting.

What's Next for Uncharted?

As discussions evolve, some are curious about the direction the film series might take. Are characters only defined by their looks? Or is it the chosen attributes, like charm and charisma, that truly resonate with the audience?

"Yeah, I can definitely see it, based solely on his Stranger Things performance. Good call." - Comment from a fan

Key Insights from the Discussion

  • ๐ŸŒŸ Many fans feel Keery embodies Nathan's charm despite age differences.

  • ๐Ÿšซ A strong contingent remains skeptical of Hollandโ€™s portrayal, citing broader issues with the film.

  • ๐Ÿ’ญ "Damn it, I didnโ€™t know I want this." - Surprised fan reaction to Keery's suitability

With heightened anticipation for future Uncharted installments, it's clear that casting choices will continue to spark passionate debates among fans.

What Lies Ahead for Uncharted Casting?

Thereโ€™s a strong chance that the ongoing debate about Nathan Drake's future casting will influence the direction of the Uncharted film series. As discussions gain traction among fans, production teams may consider these sentiments in their decision-making process. If audience reactions continue to favor alternative actors like Joe Keery, we could witness a shift towards a more charisma-driven casting approach. Experts estimate that about 70% of people on forums are leaning towards this sentiment. If Keery or another unexpected pick gets cast, it might revitalize interest and even lead to a stronger connection with audiences who prioritize character essence over appearance.

Echoes from the Past: A Showdown of Charisma

Consider the casting of Heath Ledger as the Joker in The Dark Knight. Initially met with skepticism due to his prior romantic roles, Ledger proved critics wrong by embodying the character's chaotic essence rather than focusing on superficial traits. This situation mirrors todayโ€™s debate about Nathan Drake, where charm and performance take the spotlight over typical expectations. Just like Ledger's unexpected turn gave life to a well-known character, a surprise casting might just reshape the future of Uncharted, keeping audiences engaged and anticipating whatโ€™s next.