Home
/
Fan theories
/
Character analysis
/

Joe keery's charm could suit nathan's role perfectly

Joe Keery Sparks Debate | Fans Weigh In on Nathan Drake Casting

By

Oliver Martinez

Feb 16, 2026, 03:47 PM

Edited By

Tanya Melton

Updated

Feb 17, 2026, 11:48 AM

2 minutes of duration

Joe Keery shows off his charm with a bright smile while wearing a casual shirt, capturing the attention of fans with his appeal.
popular

A fresh wave of discussion around Nathan Drake's casting in the Uncharted films is gaining momentum, with Joe Keery emerging as a strong contender. Many fans now contend he could be a better fit for the role compared to Tom Holland, favoring charisma and relatability over strict physical resemblance.

Fans Rally for Keery

Keeryโ€™s reputation from Stranger Things appears to be fueling his supporters. One fan remarked, "He has the charisma to pull it off," echoing a sentiment found across various forums.

Additionally, more names are surfacing in the mix:

  • One commenter asserted, "I honestly prefer Dylan Oโ€™Brien as Nathan Drake to be honest."

  • Another reminisced, "He is a little old now, but when Castle came out, I thought Nathan Fillion would be a good choice."

Controversial Casting Choices

Discussion around Tom Hollandโ€™s portrayal remains contentious. Supporters of Keery argue:

  • "More believable than Tom Holland"

  • "The man has the talent I donโ€™t want that for him" - raising concerns about typecasting.

  • "Day 293 of finding actors who look more like Nate than Tom Holland" - conveying ongoing frustration with current choices.

Height also plays a role in the debate; one user noted, "Heโ€™s a normal height. Nate isnโ€™t. Not asking much." Fans appear to agree that casting should reflect both character traits and authenticity. Intriguingly, some users have pointed out that Keery shares similarities with Alden Ehrenreich, adding yet another dimension to the discussion.

Future of Uncharted Casting

As the dialogue around casting intensifies, one pivotal question emerges: should iconic characters be shaped by appearance, or is it charisma that truly matters? The anticipation for upcoming Uncharted films builds, alongside a growing demand for more fitting choices in casting.

"Damn it, I didnโ€™t know I want this," one surprised fan shared, illustrating the unexpected support for Keery.

Insights from the Discussion

  • ๐ŸŒŸ Fans think Keery embodies Nathan's charm, regardless of age gaps.

  • ๐Ÿšซ A section of commenters remains critical of Holland, raising broader filmmaking concerns.

  • ๐Ÿ”„ Enthusiasts actively search for better-fit actors like Keery and Oโ€™Brien.

As excitement mounts for the Uncharted series, the collective voice of fans could have implications for future casting. If the sentiment continues to favor attractive alternatives like Keery and Oโ€™Brien, expect a shift towards more character-driven selections in films.