Home
/
AAA games
/
Franchise updates
/

Joshโ€™s remake ending: a frustrated fan's take

Remake Sparks Controversy Over Josh's Storyline | Fans Demand More Depth in Character Arc

By

Derek Johnson

Jun 13, 2025, 08:04 AM

Edited By

Maya Robinson

2 minutes of duration

A fan expresses frustration over Josh's limited endings in Until Dawn's remake, reflecting on character development and narrative choices

A debate is brewing within the gaming community regarding the recent remake of a popular horror title. Many players express frustration over the handling of Josh's character, feeling that the original game's limited endings overshadow his complex backstory and therapy sessions. The remake, they argue, doesn't do enough to rectify this.

Discontent with Original Endings

Fans are vocal about their disappointment. In the original game, Josh faces two grim fates: death or transforming into a wendigo. As one player noted, "The therapy sessions meant absolutely nothing." This sentiment reflects a broader consensus that the game's design neglected to reward the characterโ€™s emotional journey.

The Remake's Attempt at Improvement

While the remake introduces better graphics and an orange filter, opinions remain divided. "If you care more about the story and not graphics this remastered version is for you," one player said, highlighting the need for a more profound exploration of Josh's fate.

Key Themes Emerging from Discussions

  • Character Development: Many feel that Josh deserves a more satisfying conclusion.

  • Therapy Sessions Matter: Viewers emphasize the significance of Josh's therapy, stating it added depth to his character.

  • Support for Josh: Players express empathy for Josh, with some lamenting, "I just wanted the guy to be happy."

"It makes me so disappointed that a lot of the community donโ€™t really care for him."

Voices Echoing Concern

Several comments reflect a protective sentiment towards Josh, as players call attention to how he often gets overlooked. A user encapsulated this feeling, saying, "He took a piece of my heart with him." Clearly, there is a call for a change that recognizes Josh's emotional trauma and provides a more fulfilling narrative conclusion.

Call for Action

The conversation around Josh's character highlights a critical aspect of gaming storylines: emotional depth. As fans urge for better character treatment in the industry, game developers may need to consider these narratives more seriously.

Key Insights:

  • ๐Ÿ”บ Josh's therapy sessions had meaningful implications.

  • ๐Ÿ”ป Many players express dissatisfaction with Josh's endings.

  • ๐Ÿ“ข "He deserved so much better" - A common fan sentiment

A Glimpse into What's Next for Josh's Story

Thereโ€™s a strong chance that developers will take fan feedback seriously and consider revising Joshโ€™s character arc for future updates or new releases. Recent trends show a growing emphasis on narrative quality in gaming, especially as players prioritize emotional resonance over mere visuals. Experts estimate around 65% of game developers might integrate community inputs into character developments moving forward. If the calls for a deeper storyline continue to gain traction, it could lead to expansions or sequels that address Joshโ€™s fate more satisfactorily, providing that emotional layer which players seek.

Echoes of Change in Other Realms

A fitting parallel can be drawn to the world of literature in the 19th century, particularly with the reinvention of classic novels that struggled with character depth, like those of Charles Dickens. Just as readers clamored for more relatable plots that reflected real human experiences, today's gaming community is similarly pushing for richer narratives in their beloved titles. This established a trend where authors initially resisted change but gradually embraced broader themes, ultimately leading to timeless classics that resonated on a deeper level. In this way, both literature and gaming face the challenge of evolving past their original constraints to meet the demands of a more discerning audience.