The Great Debate: Just Cause 3 vs. Just Cause 4 | Gamers Weigh In
A fiery discussion is heating up among gamers on various forums as they deliberate which title in the Just Cause series claims the crown: Just Cause 3 or Just Cause 4. Passionate comments emerged on April 23, 2025, showcasing contrasting views on gameplay and narrative.
The Fans Have Spoken
Many fans voiced strong opinions about Just Cause 3, reinforcing its narrative depth. As one user mentioned, "If this board banned 'Just Cause 3 is better' posts, it’d probably die in a week." Others supported this, indicating that this viewpoint is "pretty much the most common opinion in the fandom."
Story and Mission Structure
Fans consistently pointed out that Just Cause 3 presents a tighter narrative with clearer objectives. One commenter stated, "3 has a better story and mission focus," echoing a sentiment that many supported. The looser structure of Just Cause 4 hasn’t resonated as well with some players.
Gameplay Mechanics
The debate over gameplay mechanics continues. While newcomers to Just Cause 4 praised its "cool new tether functions," opinions on wing suit mechanics varied. Some claimed the "wing suit characteristics just seemed off," reinforcing a preference for the more refined controls found in 3.
Destruction and Game Environment
Destruction mechanics in Just Cause 3 were frequently dubbed superior by commenters. As one fan noted, "the destruction is better" in JC3. The liberation system from the third game won praise, with many opting for it over 4’s chaotic style. Notably, the comments suggest a tie to nostalgia, as players recall the thrill of JC3’s missions.
"Honestly, JC3 is better in some ways, but JC4 is better in some ways as well"
— Comment from a community member
Can Both Games Coexist?
With a mix of positive and defensive tones in the discussion, it raises the question: can both games thrive despite differing opinions? While some prefer the story-driven experience of Just Cause 3, others see value in the newer title's gameplay aspects.
Insights from the Ongoing Debate
△ Strong preference for the narrative and mission focus in Just Cause 3
▽ Mixed sentiments regarding gameplay mechanics between titles
※ "This point has been beaten to death. Almost everyone prefers 3"
As gamers continue to voice their preferences, the rivalry between these two entries remains vibrant. Each title has carved out a unique place in the hearts of fans, ensuring the debate is far from over.