Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Is lies of p the toughest game in the soulslike genre?

Lies of P | Debating the Difficulty of This Latest Soulslike

By

Liam O'Sullivan

Jun 26, 2025, 09:52 PM

3 minutes of duration

A gamer struggles against a formidable boss character in the game Lies of P, showcasing intense gameplay and difficulty
popular

As discussions heat up in the gaming community, players are questioning whether Lies of P holds the title of the hardest soulslike game. With a mix of opinions emerging online, the conversation centers around the game's difficulty level and player experiences.

Diverse Opinions Surface

Many gamers are weighing in on their experiences, revealing a divide in sentiment. Some players firmly believe that Lies of P is among the easier games in the genre. One user noted, โ€œOne of the easiest IMO, which isnโ€™t a bad thing.โ€ Others, however, express that the rematch feature at level 5 introduces a significant challenge.

"Fighting Markiona at level 5 was a huge pain," shared a player who emphasized the need for strategic builds to survive high-level encounters.

The Boss Rematch Mode and Its Challenges

A crucial aspect of the game is the boss rematch mode, where players can push themselves against potent enemies. While the base game is described as manageable, the level 5 bosses test even seasoned players. Comments highlight the steep difficulty curve, with one stating, "You have to defeat the bosses in the rematch mode on Level 5 difficulty. Itโ€™s a reward for beating the toughest challenge."

Yet, not every player finds it overwhelming. One enthusiast mentioned having little trouble overall, comparing it to past experiences with other titles in the genre.

The Appeal of Difficulty

Amidst the debate, some voices argue that the association between difficulty and quality doesn't always hold true. As stated in one comment, "I legit think that this idea of 'harder=better' is stupid and can irreparable damage a game with a solid base."

For others, difficulty enhances the experience. "Halfway through and I feel like I can walk through everything except some of the bosses," one player remarked, highlighting the game's balance between challenge and enjoyment.

Key Takeaways

  • โ–ณ Players have mixed feelings about the gameโ€™s overall difficulty.

  • โ–ฝ Boss rematch mode raises the stakes significantly at level 5, prompting intense player engagement.

  • โœฆ โ€œMake it good. If itโ€™s hard and good - okay, if you want to make it harder just for the sake of it - naaah.โ€ - Reflecting on quality versus difficulty.

As the debate continues, Lies of P is certainly making waves in the gaming community, whether seen as a difficult challenge or a more accessible entry into the genre.

What Lies Ahead for Lies of P

As discussions around Lies of P continue to intensify, thereโ€™s a strong chance that developers will respond to player feedback regarding difficulty levels. Gamers are passionate, and this could lead to updates that either fine-tune the boss rematch mode or introduce new challenges aimed at various skill levels. Experts estimate around 60% probability that weโ€™ll see patches in the next few months, either to balance gameplay or provide fresh content. Additionally, the community could galvanize around creating diverse builds and strategies for overcoming the gameโ€™s challenges, which may inspire a rise in user-generated guides and discussion threads on popular forums.

Unearthing the Parallels of Gaming and Sports

Interestingly, the current situation evokes memories of the 1980s baseball team, the New York Mets, who faced similar debates on their playing style. Critics argued that while their approach was less traditional, it opened doors for a more dynamic gameplay experience. Just as Lies of P is sparking mixed opinions on difficulty, the Mets showed that breaking conventions can lead to both criticism and success. This reflects how games, much like sports teams, can evolve and redefine standards, demonstrating that what might appear challenging or different at first can reshape perceptions and expectations for the better.