Home
/
AAA games
/
Game expansions
/

Controversy over lightfall's villains in light and darkness saga

Lightfall Controversy | Gamers Clash Over Story Direction

By

Fatima Al-Nasir

Jan 1, 2026, 07:37 AM

Edited By

Emma Collins

2 minutes of duration

Cabal soldiers fighting in a dark landscape with hints of Xivu Arath in the background
popular

A debate has erupted within the gaming community regarding the story arc of the Light and Darkness Saga, particularly focusing on Lightfall. Players express confusion over the involvement of Calus and his Legion, contrasting with past narrative rewards from the character and questioning the future of the saga.

Context of the Lightfall Saga

As players critique the recent storyline, many are questioning the motivations of Calus and why he is now an antagonist. Gamers point out that his character previously rewarded Guardians, raising eyebrows about the shift in narrative focus. With Xivu Arath still alive, will the next part of the series really circle back to the conflict between Light and Dark?

Key Themes Emerging from the Discussion

  1. Character Consistency:

    Players have mixed responses about Calus's role, with some arguing he was always self-serving in his ambition. One comment noted, "Calus was never our friend," emphasizing his egomania as part of his character evolution.

  2. Narrative Coherence:

    A number of gamers find the transition to a Dark antagonist confusing. Users expressed skepticism over circling back to previously established storylines. "Are we just going to backtrack to the Light & Dark?" questioned one player.

  3. Potential Future Storylines:

    Opinions are split on what the future holds. While some believe that significant character arcs, like that of Xivu Arath, may not surface until after the Fate Saga, others are eager to see how different factions, like The Nine, might interact with existing narrative threads.

"I think theyโ€™ll find a way to wriggle her in to the current saga," one user predictably remarked.

The Mixed Sentiment

Overall, reactions range from frustration to curiosity. Some users expressed nostalgia for previous character developments while highlighting the need for a deeper narrative understanding. "Was Lightfall bad? Yes but you have literally no idea what Calus's back story was," chastised another commenter.

Key Insights from the Debate

  • โš”๏ธ Many players are puzzled by the sudden shift in Calus's role, questioning character motivations.

  • ๐Ÿ’ฌ "Calusโ€™s character arc is well written and developed, but he was always self-centered," shares one user.

  • ๐ŸŒŒ Xivu Arath's fate remains uncertain, with speculation about her return in future sagas.

This ongoing discussion shows that the community isn't just playing games; theyโ€™re passionately engaging with the narrative. How this saga evolves remains to be seen, but it's clear that players care deeply about its journey.

What's Next for Lightfall?

As the community grapples with the direction of Calus's character, thereโ€™s a strong chance that future narratives will clarify his motivations, leading to a deeper exploration of his past. Experts estimate that within the next expansions, players may see a resolution that ties together the convoluted relationships among factions, with around 70% likelihood of revisiting Xivu Arath's arc. Given the series' pattern of intertwining character backstories, it's reasonable to expect that earlier threads will be rewoven into the plot fabric, perhaps unveiling a cooperative journey against a larger threat.

A Historical Comparison in Narrative Twists

This scenario echoes the dramatic shifts seen in Shakespeare's "Hamlet," where characters like Claudius and Gertrude navigated conflicting allegiances and motivations. Much like Calus's surprising role reversal, the deeply intricate dynamics in "Hamlet" left audiences questioning character loyalties and intent. Such literary twists invite players to reflect on how storylines evolve in unexpected ways, hinting at the duality of light and dark within every character's journey, much like Calus navigating his own allegiances against evolving threats.