Players Split Over Linear Souls Games | Some Claim They Outshine Elden Ring
A lively debate across gaming forums has drawn attention to linear Soulslike games as some players contend they offer a more rewarding experience than the expansive format of Elden Ring. As discussions heat up in 2026, opinions reveal strong divides among gamers regarding gameplay preferences.
Exploring the Shift in Player Preference
Many players are voicing their frustrations with the vastness of Elden Ring, claiming it can lessen overall enjoyment. Recent contributions show a noticeable movement back towards linear gameplay, where storylines are straightforward and completion feels more attainable.
"Finishing a good game gives me huge satisfaction," stated a player who recently pivoted back to linear narratives.
Key Themes from the Community Comments
Praise for Linear Titles: Players are increasingly highlighting games like Lies of P, which they see as excellent examples of linear game design. A player remarked, "You should play Lies of P. Mad linear," indicating enthusiasm for its focused narrative.
Comparison with Sekiro: There are mixed views on Sekiro, regarded as open yet curated compared to Dark Souls. One player noted, "Sekiro really is a masterpiece. Elden Ring feels overwhelming and too big for me personally."
Open World Fatigue: Users have expressed fatigue with larger game worlds. Comments revealed that players often lose interest midway through titles like Elden Ring. As one user noted, "Compared to all the linear games, Elden Ring falls short."
Community Sentiment
The prevailing tone remains critical of Elden Ring’s open-world approach, with many gamers expressing a desire for more direct gaming experiences. While some still appreciate the freedom offered by open-world mechanics, the longing for structured narratives is evident.
Notable Insights from the Debate
🔄 Many players are tilting toward story-driven experiences, favoring linear games for their clarity.
⚡ Complaints about Elden Ring’s extensive exploration features are common, with calls for increased direction in gameplay.
"Not every game is for everyone" - A potent reminder of the variety of tastes in gaming.
With a clear trend shifting towards linear storytelling, developers may take note as discussions continue throughout 2026. The demand for concise, engaging gameplay experiences is palpable, prompting potential innovation in future game designs.