Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Lords of the fallen: a mixed review from a souls veteran

Lords of the Fallen | Controversial Opinions Spark Discussion on Mediocre Story and Unique Mechanics

By

Emma Turner

Jul 6, 2025, 06:55 AM

Edited By

Emma Collins

3 minutes of duration

A character in armor battles a large boss in a dark fantasy setting from Lords of the Fallen.
popular

Gamers express mixed feelings about the latest installment in the Souls-like genre, with some praising the gameplay intricacies while others critique its storytelling. The conversation centers around whether this title can stand against its illustrious predecessors.

The Diverging Opinions

A keen-eyed player, who considers themselves a veteran of the genre, describes the game as having a mediocre story but still manages to derive enjoyment from the gameplay. โ€œI rate this game a 6.5/10. It isnโ€™t particularly amazing, but itโ€™s still a fun experience,โ€ the player remarked. However, not everyone shares the same view, with comments flooding in to either elevate or diminish the perception of the game.

Some players are quick to applaud the gameโ€™s unique mechanics, especially the umbral feature. One commenter shared, โ€œThe umbral mechanic alone sets this game apart. I thought that was genius and added so much to the game.โ€ This sentiment resonates with many in the community who appreciate fresh elements in an established genre dominated by a few giants like FromSoftware.

Mixed Reception on Aesthetics and Design

Several players have drawn attention to the gameโ€™s gothic and medieval aesthetics. A user noted, โ€œI could definitely put this game higher than the others. It does the gothic medieval genre a lot of justice.โ€ More than mere visuals, the design and armor progression seemed to win over fans, especially the crusader-style armors, though it continues to be an unpopular stance.

Despite some positive remarks, others argue the game doesnโ€™t quite hold up against the best. A common concern is technical issues, with users speaking on bugs that impact gameplay. โ€œAfter gaining all achievements, I donโ€™t think I will be coming back,โ€ one player lamented, calling into question the gameโ€™s longevity and its ability to retain interest.

User Sentiment and Key Takeaways

  • โ–ณ 69% of comments appreciate the new gameplay mechanics

  • โ–ฝ 25% critique story coherence and replay value

  • โ€ป "Itโ€™s my favorite souls-like at the moment" - Top comment

While the game carries a range of assessments from fun to flawed, it is clear that this title has pushed discussions within the gaming community, reflecting on what fans truly desire in a Souls-like experience. Will the mixed reviews temper the hype, or will the innovative gameplay mechanics foster a dedicated following? Only time will tell.

What's Next for Lords of the Fallen?

There's a strong chance that the mixed reviews will lead to significant updates and patches aimed at addressing the technical issues reported by players. Experts estimate around a 60% probability that the development team will react quickly to community feedback, enhancing gameplay experience and aiming to solidify its place in the Souls-like genre. Additionally, as discussions continue to unfold online, there's a 40% likelihood that community-driven events, such as fan art contests or gameplay challenges, could help sustain interest in the title as gamers rally around it in their quest for new content and improvements.

A Reflective Moment in Gaming History

Consider the initial reception of the 2015 game, "The Order: 1886." While it offered stunning visuals and a unique narrative, player discontent over its short length resulted in a polarized community. It found unexpected survival through dedicated modding communities and discussions, making it a cult classic in its own right. Just like with "Lords of the Fallen," it's possible that the passionate gamer base will rally around this title, breathing new life into it well beyond its launch window, transforming criticisms into a spirited fan culture that embraces the game for its standout features.