Souls-Like Starter Showdown | Is LotF Your Best Bet?

Fatima Khan

Apr 30, 2025, 02:55 AM

Edited By

James Lee

Updated

Apr 30, 2025, 04:29 PM

Snappy read

Screenshot of gameplay in Lotf showcasing a character battling a creature in a dark environment.

A growing conversation is unfolding around Lords of the Fallen (LotF) as a potential starting point for new gamers in the souls-like genre. With prices dipping, opinions on forums show sharp divides. Some players continue to advocate for FromSoftware’s titles as the ideal initiation.

Detractors of LotF as a First Choice

Many players are vocal against starting with LotF. One user bluntly stated, "Nah. There’s so much better out there. Go with Elden Ring, it’s a masterpiece." The preference for the classics remains strong, with comments like "Absolutely not" indicating a clear stance on lesser alternatives.

"When you say first soulslike, are you including the Fromsoft games? Because you definitely need to play those first."

A Defense for LotF

In contrast, some voices argue LotF provides a solid entry. A player said, "Honestly, LotF is a pretty solid game. It’s not a bad one to get your feet wet with." Another highlighted its accessibility, mentioning, "If you’re worried about the difficulty of most souls games, this is about 40% easier than FromSoftware's works." This view presents LotF not just as a game but as a stepping stone for newcomers.

Interestingly, others point out the game's flexibility. One commenter noted, "In Elden Ring, there is ALWAYS something else to do if you feel stuck." This adaptability is contrasted with the more linear challenge of traditional souls-like titles.

Themes in the Discussion

🌟 A significant number favor FromSoftware games as the go-to for first-time players.
✅ Some argue that LotF can serve as a less daunting introduction to the souls-like genre.
📉 The feedback is mixed, with many expressing hesitations about jumping in with LotF.

Finale on LotF as a Launch Point

The debate around LotF brings to light how varied the entry points into the souls-like genre can be. While FromSoftware remains a benchmark for excellence, LotF seems to offer an alternative for those who may find the classic route intimidating without compromising the core experience.