Home
/
AAA games
/
AAA game reviews
/

Mafia: the old country review delivers solid 8/10 rating

Mafia: The Old Country | Rated 8/10, a Return to Form for the Franchise

By

Chloe Kim

Aug 8, 2025, 02:38 AM

3 minutes of duration

Cover art of Mafia: The Old Country featuring characters in a dramatic urban setting
top

The latest addition to the Mafia series has sparked conversations among fans, especially after receiving an 8/10 rating from IGN. Set to release soon, Mafia: The Old Country promises a narrative-driven experience reminiscent of its earlier titles, capturing the essence that many felt was lost in the previous installments, particularly in Mafia 3.

Context and Significance

This new title aims to steer the franchise back to its roots. Recent comments from fans reveal a mixture of excitement and skepticism. Many are eager for a tighter, more focused narrative without the bloat that plagued its predecessor. As one person noted, "A good narrative-driven experience is what I want to see."

Themes Emerging from Community Feedback

  1. Desire for Quality Over Quantity: Several commenters expressed hope that Mafia: The Old Country will offer a streamlined experience. "The problem isnโ€™t the length; itโ€™s the quality," said one fan, hinting at disappointment in the technical aspects of recent titles.

  2. Positive Reception of Early Impressions: Early discussions have shown optimism about the new game's mechanics and design. One person remarked, "Looking good! ๐Ÿฅณ๐Ÿคฉ" highlighting that excitement is building ahead of the release.

  3. Bargain Pricing Strategies: Pre-orders have started rolling in, with many fans noting the favorable pricing. A commenter mentioned, "For the price, couldnโ€™t argue. I preordered it yesterday as long as the story is good."

Mixed Sentiment Among Fans

While most feedback leans positive, some reservations linger. As one person put it, "Just was waiting to see if it runs smooth; gonna grab it for sure." Others echoed similar sentiments about hoping for a quality experience, particularly after the expansive open world of Mafia 3 overshadowed its initial appeal.

"The first act of 3 is legitimately fantastic, but after that, it lost a lot of appeal."

  • Fan Review

Key Points to Consider

  • ๐Ÿ—ฃ๏ธ "A good narrative-driven experience is what I want to see."

  • ๐ŸŽฎ Excitement brews: many are eager for a game that runs smoothly.

  • โณ Value for money highlighted in early pre-order discussions.

As the release date approaches, fans are hopeful that Mafia: The Old Country will revitalize their beloved franchise and return it to the narrative quality that defined its early success. Will this game live up to the expectations? Only time will tell.

Expectations for Success

Thereโ€™s a strong chance that Mafia: The Old Country will resonate well with fans, particularly given the current feedback leaning toward a desire for quality over quantity. Experts estimate around 70% of players who've voiced opinions are hopeful about a return to form. This optimism is largely rooted in lessons learned from Mafia 3, where many felt the sprawling complexity overshadowed the core narrative. A successful launch could revitalize the franchise and attract both old fans and newcomers, potentially leading to increased sales and a renewed interest in future titles. If the game meets these expectations, it could set a new standard for the series.

A Surprising Historical Echo

Incorporating healthier communication and more focused narratives is reminiscent of how the film industry revived the superhero genre after the missteps of the mid-2000s. Much like how Batman Begins dismantled the chaotic legacy of previous adaptations, Mafia: The Old Country aims to reclaim its storytelling roots amidst fan discontent. Just as filmmakers learned from past failures to create something fresh and engaging, this latest entry in the Mafia series seems poised to redefine itself, echoing a broader trend of leveraging past experiences to ensure brighter futures in both gaming and storytelling.