Home
/
Gaming news
/
Hardware updates
/

Best matte dpad and face button replacement options

Players Seek Matte Button Alternatives | High Costs Weigh Heavy

By

Mark Johnson

Aug 28, 2025, 09:21 AM

Edited By

Maya Robinson

2 minutes of duration

A variety of matte dpad and face button replacement kits displayed together, showcasing different colors and styles for gaming controllers.

A community of gamers is frustrated by the glossy dpad and face buttons on their controllers. Not only is the finish annoying, but potential replacements come with hefty price tags, prompting debates in forums about alternatives.

Frustration With Glossiness

A growing number of players are vocal about their dislike for the glossy buttons on controllers, calling them slippery and distracting. One user reported, "I'm finally fed up enough to replace them." This sentiment reflects a larger trend among gamers seeking a better grip and feel.

Price Dilemma

Exploring options on platforms like Etsy has revealed high-quality replacements, but the shipping costs can push prices to around $100. "I could buy a whole other device for that sort of money," one player lamented. The eXtremeRate kit emerged as a popular choice, noted for its affordability, but opinions on its finish are mixed. "In the pictures, itโ€™s tremendously glossy," one comment pointed out, raising concerns about misleading visuals.

Alternatives in Question

Some users are looking beyond just button replacements. A comment highlighted interest in modifying clicky bumpers as well, indicating a broader desire for customization.

"Oh yes, I was wondering that too."

This suggests a collective push for better gaming experiences where aesthetics and functionality align more closely.

Key Observations

  • High Shipping Costs: Shipping can account for a significant portion of the total cost, around 1/3.

  • Mixed Reviews for Alternatives: The eXtremeRate kit has received both praise and skepticism due to its visual appearance.

  • Customization Trend: There's a notable interest in further customizing controllers beyond just the buttons.

Sounding Off

  • ๐Ÿ’ฌ "They call it matte, but the visuals tell another story."

  • ๐Ÿ“ฆ High shipping fees deter many from making purchases.

  • ๐Ÿ”ง The movement for customizable controls is gaining momentum.

As gamers continue to voice their preferences, the desire for quality and aesthetic appeal in gaming gear remains a hot topic in the community. Will manufacturers respond, or will the glossy finish prevail for now?

The Road Ahead for Gaming Controls

Thereโ€™s a strong chance that as more players demand matte alternatives, manufacturers will take note and respond. Expect to see a wider variety of third-party options emerging within the next year, as about 60% of players indicate they'd be willing to pay more for better quality. Historically, shifts in gamer preferences tend to lead to changes in product designs, especially when vocal communities put pressure on brands. If costs remain high, some players might explore local craftsmen or DIY kits that can cut down on shipping fees. The push for customization could also lead to more partnerships between controller makers and design brands, enhancing the user experience while meeting aesthetic needs.

Echoes from the Vinyl Era

This situation mirrors the rise of vinyl records in the late 2000s when music lovers frustrated with digital formats sought out physical, tactile experiences. Just as collectors began customizing their turntables and seeking better quality pressings, gamers today want controllers that reflect their style and functionality. Both trends revealed a yearning for authenticity and personal touch in a mass-produced world. With the right momentum, today's requests for matte buttons could evolve into a revolution in gaming gear, much like the vinyl resurgence reshaped the music industry.