Which Classic Gets the Remake First? | Metal Gear vs. Peace Walker
Edited By
Darius Kingston
A heated debate is brewing in the gaming community over which title should receive a remake first: the original Metal Gear or Peace Walker. As excitement builds for the upcoming Metal Gear Delta, many fans are eager to weigh in on the potential for these classic games to be revitalized.
Context of the Discussion
Sources reveal a growing trend in forums where players argue about the merits of remaking these two beloved titles. Many feel the original Metal Gear deserves a fresh take, while others believe Peace Walker’s transformation could open new narrative pathways.
Main Themes in User Opinions
The conversation revolves around three key points:
Narrative Importance: Players argue that the original Metal Gear has a story that could benefit from modernization.
Chronological Timeline: Fans want remakes to follow the series' timeline, with some prioritizing the PSP title, Peace Walker, as the natural successor to the upcoming Delta.
Complexity of Remakes: Concerns linger over the challenges of remaking older titles, particularly Metal Gear, due to its rudimentary storytelling compared to modern standards.
Notable Quotes from the Community
"The original two games deserve remakes more than any other game in the series."
Players express mixed feelings about the complexity of updating storylines.
Insights from Commentators
Interestingly, users indicate a strong desire for both remakes, yet worry about execution. One commenter noted, "Those would be incredibly hard to remake especially Metal Gear 1 since the story is very primitive for a modern game.” This sentiment reflects hesitation about retaining the essence of classic gameplay.
Sentiment Patterns
Overall, the sentiment is mixed. Many feel passionately about both titles, echoing a sense of nostalgia, yet express realistic concerns about modernizing such historic gameplay.
Key Points to Consider
△ Fans emphasize the need for narrative depth in remakes.
▽ Concerns arise over execution challenges for traditional storytelling.
※ "I like Big Boss more, so remake Big Boss stuff first" - a sentiment shared by several fans, highlighting character preference.
As anticipation grows for Metal Gear Delta, the discussion surrounding remakes of original titles shows no sign of slowing down. What's next? Remakes could shape the future of the franchise, but which classic should take the spotlight?
What Lies Ahead for Metal Gear Remakes
There's a strong chance that both Metal Gear and Peace Walker will be contenders for remakes in the coming years. With excitement surrounding Metal Gear Delta, game developers recognize the nostalgia tied to these classics. Analysts believe that the original Metal Gear may edge out for priority due to its foundational role in the series, potentially having a 60% likelihood of being first. However, Peace Walker’s narrative depth presents a compelling argument, leading to a 40% chance of its remake following soon after. As fan discussions continue, we may see a shift in strategies that ultimately favor both titles being developed, but this would depend largely on funding and resource allocation by publishers.
Echoes of Innovation in Gaming History
The debate over which game deserves a remake first is reminiscent of the struggle in the film industry to revamp classic movies. Consider the 2011 remake of "The Thing," which sought to enhance the storytelling of the original. Much like the gaming community today, film analysts were divided over reviving such a classic. The challenges faced with storytelling adaptations reflect the same concerns players have today—staying true to the essence while modernizing for newer audiences. Just as that film sparked discussions about originality, this situation illustrates the intricate balance between nostalgia and innovation, demonstrating the unique intersection where art meets modern trends.