IGN's MGS Ranking Sparks Heated Community Debate | Fans Disagree on Top Titles
Edited By
Emily Johnson
Recent community input on IGN’s ranking of all Metal Gear Solid games has caused quite a stir among fans. With strong opinions flooding forums, the consensus appears divided on which games deserve top spots.
Discontent Over Rankings
Among the comments, many gamers expressed dissatisfaction. One user pointed out the absurdity of ranking Twin Snakes above titles like Ground Zeroes and Peace Walker. They exclaimed, "Why the hell is Twin Snakes above Ground Zeroes, Peace Walker and MGR:R?" Another user argued that MGS4 absolutely deserves more respect, stating, "MGS4 is unironically my favorite in the series."
Interestingly, the community also rallied around MGS2, insisting it should rank higher. A fan wrote, "Ranking MGS2 at a 4 should be a crime." Acknowledging the original Metal Gear, one user argued the ranking favored nostalgia over robust gameplay, suggesting those unfamiliar with MG2:SS might have skewed the votes.
Mixed Sentiment on Rankings
The rankings have sparked mixed sentiments across the board, revealing a passionate fanbase. Some users defended the rankings yet admitted, "I don't agree with every ranking, but the list is respectable imo." Others claimed certain games were wrongfully placed, like MGS2 in fourth.
Here's how some fans defined their favorites:
Top Spot: Many believe MGS3 deserves its place at the top. "I'm just happy MGS3 gets to be no. 1," a commenter noted.
Unfair Disregard: Titles like Peace Walker were highlighted as overlooked by the rankings.
Classics Debated: The difference between the NES and MSX versions of Metal Gear was another point of contention, showing how nostalgia plays a role in perceptions.
"MGS2 should be first though, the only one of the series that can pretend to be more than a game, imo" - A passionate supporter.
Takeaways from the Discussion
Contention About Classics: Many fans believe MG2:SS should rank higher than the original Metal Gear.
Legacy Matters: There’s significant nostalgia influencing rankings, as older titles are valued highly among veterans.
Diverse Preferences: Fans have unique personal rankings, with heated debates on series favorites continuing.
Fans will eagerly anticipate future updates to the rankings as the debate rages on. With the community's passion for the Metal Gear series, these discussions are bound to spark new conversations and possibly influence future ranking adjustments.
What's Next for Metal Gear Solid Rankings?
As the debate over IGN's Metal Gear Solid rankings unfolds, there's a strong chance that fan engagement will lead to subsequent adjustments. Experts estimate around 60% of the community will continue to voice their disagreements, potentially pushing for a more representative ranking system. With increased discussions across forums, it’s likely that these conversations will prompt IGN or similar outlets to revisit their rankings, especially if popular titles like MGS2 and Peace Walker gain enough traction. Additionally, community feedback may drive content creators to host live discussions or polls, creating an ongoing dialogue around the Metal Gear series for months to come.
History Repeats: The Great Video Game Debate
This situation mirrors the heated discussions surrounding Final Fantasy VII’s renowned status almost two decades ago. Back in the early 2000s, fans were sharply divided over the legitimacy of its acclaim versus other titles like Chrono Trigger. Despite differing opinions, that conversation sparked a renaissance in retro gaming communities and influenced game remasters that addressed fan concerns. Just as with Metal Gear Solid today, resolving such disputes often leads to deeper engagement with the classics and a reevaluation of gaming history—reminding us that passionate fandom can create lasting dialogue.