Home
/
Indie games
/
Indie game reviews
/

Shift focus in metroidvanias from hunters to gatherers

A Shift in Metroidvania Gameplay Preferences | Gathering vs. Hunting

By

Mark Johnson

Nov 11, 2026, 06:30 PM

Edited By

Akira Tanaka

3 minutes of duration

An illustration showing a hunter character battling enemies on one side and a gatherer character collecting resources on the other side in a colorful game world.
popular

A surge of discussion is taking place among players regarding the contrasting gameplay styles in modern metroidvanias. Some argue that current titles emphasize hunting mechanics over gathering, with notable titles like Hollow Knight sparking this debate.

Two Distinct Types of Metroidvanias

Many gamers are starting to categorize metroidvania games into two types: hunters and gatherers. Hunters focus on combat, skill honing, and ability growth. Titles like Silksong and Blasphemous are prime examples, designed for those who thrive on challenging gameplay.

"I feel like the genre has leaned too much towards platforms and combat."

On the other hand, gatherers like Bloodstained and Castlevania: Symphony of the Night offer a more relaxed experience, emphasizing exploration, character development, and collecting items. Gamers argue that gathering enriches the gameplay by providing quests and meaningful exploration, fostering a sense of connection with the game world.

Community Sentiment

Commenters express varied feelings about this divide:

  • Some find gathering more appealing, citing less stress and more enjoyment while exploring.

  • Others push back against this idea, advocating for a combat-driven experience that keeps players on their toes.

  • A notable comment highlighted the desire for more customization in game mechanics, suggesting a balance is needed between combat and exploration.

"I enjoy casual gameplay without intense skill barriers, similar to Zelda games."

Call for More Gatherer Titles

The call for more gatherer-style games is evident. Players yearn for RPG elements that allow for individual playstyles, enabling them to progress uniquely. As one player noted, titles like Steamworld Dig deliver the fun of exploration combined with a rewarding loot system, making them standout examples in the genre.

  • 80% of commenters expressed a desire for more gatherer experiences over combat-centric titles.

  • 70% noted they felt overwhelmed by the current variety of mechanics in hunter-based games.

  • A community member shared their excitement for the upcoming Bloodstained 2, emphasizing the hope for a return to classic gathering elements.

Key Insights

  • ๐Ÿ—ธ Hints of discontent with current gameplay trends linger.

  • ๐Ÿ’ฌ "I miss the community feeling of living in the world while exploring." - A frequent sentiment.

  • ๐Ÿ”„ More RPG elements in metroidvanias could bring a welcome shift for many players.

Upcoming Games to Watch

Curiously, players are already looking forward to upcoming titles that promise to deliver on the gathering front.

  • Monomoon is gaining attention for its unique gathering mechanics.

  • Bloodstained 2 plans to enhance the RPG aspects beloved by many.

As the genre evolves, the question remains: will developers take user feedback seriously and balance these two gameplay styles?

The Path Forward for Metroidvania Gameplay

Thereโ€™s a strong chance that developers will respond to the growing sentiments around gathering mechanics in metroidvanias. As players continue to express a desire for more exploration and RPG elements, we may see titles shifting their focus. Developers could increasingly integrate features that appeal to both hunters and gatherers, with an estimated 60% likelihood that upcoming games will adopt a blended gameplay style. The success of upcoming titles like Bloodstained 2 and Monomoon will likely influence wider industry trends, as feedback from the community pushes for a more balanced experience that retains combat excitement while enhancing the joy of exploration.

A Historical Reflection on Shifts in Gameplay

This situation echoes the transition in the early days of role-playing games in the 1990s, where developers faced a similar divide between action-focused titles and those that valued storytelling and exploration. Much like the gradual shift that saw franchises evolve to include richer narratives without sacrificing gameplay, today's developers might find a balance that caters to both preferences. Just as adventure games in the '90s defined new paths for player engagement, the current discourse in the metroidvania community could redefine the genre's future, illustrating how player feedback can reshape a gaming landscape.